Trophic niche comparison of three species of Culter from the middle and upper reaches of the Yangtze River
NI Wenjing,DENG Huatang,HE Chun,PU Yan,TIAN Huiwu,LIU Shaoping,CHEN Daqing,DUAN Xinbin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.12264/jfsc2022-0361
2023-01-01
Journal of Fishery Sciences of China
Abstract:Culter species, as carnivorous fishes in lakes and reservoirs in the middle and upper reaches of the Yangtze River, usually play the top predator role in the freshwater ecosystem. Culter dabryi, Culter mongolicus,and Culter alburnus are the most common and abundant Culter species in these regions. Because of sympatry and predatory habits, these Culter species seemingly have interspecific resources competition, which could be fierce especially when food resources are limited. In addition, the changes in their population could have an important impact on other fish species or communities through top-down effects. To understand the interspecific trophic relationships of Culter in the middle and upper reaches of the Yangtze River, carbon and nitrogen stable isotope analysis technology and isotope-derived metrics were used to examine stable isotope characteristics and trophic interrelations of these three Culter species samples from the upper reaches, reservoir reaches, and the middle reaches. A one-way analysis of variance（ANOVA） was used to test whether there were significant differences in δ 13 C and δ 15 N values among the three Culter species in each river section. Six quantitative metrics in the bi-plot space, including δ 13 C range（CR）, δ 15 N range（NR）, mean distance to centroid（CD）, mean nearest neighbor distance（MNND）, standard deviation of the nearest neighbor distance（SDNND）, and total area（TA） derived from stable isotope data, were used to describe trophic niche space, trophic diversity, and redundancy. Instead of total area（TA）, which is highly sensitive to sample size, standard ellipse area（SEA） was also used to quantify the trophic niche space of each species. Besides, to provide more robust metrics and allow for statistical comparisons among sites and species, Bayesian methodology was implemented to generate a posterior distribution of estimates of these metrics. The results showed that δ 13 C values of the three Culter species differed significantly（P＜0.05） in each region, while the significant disparity of δ 15 N values only appeared in the upper reaches of the river（P＜0.05）,indicating that there were spatial differences in the food sources and trophic levels among the three species. The results of multi-trophic ecological niche indicators showed that C. mongolicus had the highest SEAB（Bayesian standard ellipse area） values in all river sections, and the probability of its SEAB being greater than the SEAB values of the other two Culter species ranged from 74.7% to 96.4%. Additionally, the Bayesian results of the CR,CD, and MNND indicators were also highest in the middle and upper reaches of the Yangtze River, indicating that C. mongolicus has a wider food source and occupies a larger trophic niche space. In most cases, the niche width of C. mongolicus is larger than those of C. dabryi and C. alburnus, which may be related to the fact that C.mongolicus has a wide mouth end position and a sparse gill rake that facilitates food passage. The results of stable isotope standard ellipse area overlap showed that there were spatial differences in the niche space overlap among three Culter species. Among them, the highest overlap of stable isotope ellipsoidal area（0.522） was found between C. mongolicus and C. alburnus in the midstream, which accounted for 62.4% and 76.3% of the total SEA of each species, respectively. The SEA overlap between C. dabryi and C. alburnus was lower, only about 0.1 in the upper or middle reaches and no overlap was observed in the reservoir area. Generally, the overlaps between C.mongolicus and C. alburnus or C. dabryi were higher than other pairwise comparisons. These results indicated that C. mongolicus are more liable to have feeding competition with the other two Culter species in the middle and upper reaches of the Yangtze River. Nevertheless, there appeared a certain niche differentiation of food resources between C. alburnus and C. dabryi due to their preference for feeding on their dominant food.