A Comparative Study of Four Age Validation Structures for Common Carp (Cyprinus carpio)in Dianchi Lake in Yunnan,China
Xiao LI,Jian-zhong SHEN,Jiang GONG,Wen-juan YU,Ya-hui ZHANG,Zong-dong LI
DOI: https://doi.org/10.15928/j.1674-3075.2015.05.014
2015-01-01
Abstract:Validation of fish age is the foundation for fish growth and age structure analysis as well as estimating the death rate of a fish population.Calcified structures of fish produce periodic growth increments useful for age deter-mination at the annual scale.Determining proper structures for age validation increases the accuracy and precision of fish aging.The international community of researchers has not reached a consensus on which of the four calcified structures (lapillus,scale,pectoral fin and operculum)is the best for determining the age of Cyprinus carpio and all have been used.In China,only scales have been used for Cyprinus carpio aging and some researchers have sug-gested that pectoral fins and opercula are not suitable for aging Cyprinus carpio.Furthermore,fish growth is influ-enced by environmental factors which could cause variation in the incremental deposition to the different calcified structures and this should be considered when selecting the most suitable age validation structure.In this paper,we describe the morphology and annuli characteristics of four aging materials (lapillus,scale,pectoral fin and opercu-lum)for common carp in Dianchi Lake of Yunnan province,China.The agreement among the four calcified struc-tures for determining the age of common carp in Dianchi Lake was also analyzed.584 common carp with body length 7.5 -50.5 cm and body weight 17.2 -3 211.3 g were collected by trawling in Dianchi Lake during May and June and from August to November of 2013,and from March to July of 2014.A total of 584 lapillus speci-mens,276 scale specimens,276 operculum specimens and 274 pectoral fin specimens were prepared and all speci-mens were observed and photographed under a dissecting microscope.The results show that the incremental deposi-tion on the lapillus of common carp was distinct,demonstrating an obvious alternate opaque zone and translucent zone under reflected light.Among the four structures,the sectioned lapilli showed the highest percentage agreement (88.0%)between duplicate age readings by the same observer,followed by scales (84.1%),pectoral fins (73.7%)and opercula (72.1%).The average percent error for the duplicate age readings on sectioned lapilli, scales,pectoral fins and opercula were 2.6% and 2.9%,4.7% and 5.9%,respectively.Furthermore,compared with the age validation by sectioned lapilli,scales showed the highest percentage agreement (77.5%)and the low-est coefficient of variations (6.14%),while opercula and pectoral fins gave only 61.9% and 56.2% percentage a-greement with sectioned lapilli.The first annuli of the opercula and pectoral fins were both difficult to confirm and the coefficient of variation for the two materials were both over 12%.To summarize,sectioned lapilli are the best age determination material for common carp in Dianchi Lake.Scales can be used for age determination of individu-als less than 4 years old,while opercula and pectoral fins are not suitable for determining the age of common carp.