Abstract:Although rarely stated, in practice, Grammatical Error Correction (GEC) encompasses various models with distinct objectives, ranging from grammatical error detection to improving fluency. Traditional evaluation methods fail to fully capture the full range of system capabilities and objectives. Reference-based evaluations suffer from limitations in capturing the wide variety of possible correction and the biases introduced during reference creation and is prone to favor fixing local errors over overall text improvement. The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has further highlighted the shortcomings of these evaluation strategies, emphasizing the need for a paradigm shift in evaluation methodology. In the current study, we perform a comprehensive evaluation of various GEC systems using a recently published dataset of Swedish learner texts. The evaluation is performed using established evaluation metrics as well as human judges. We find that GPT-3 in a few-shot setting by far outperforms previous grammatical error correction systems for Swedish, a language comprising only 0.11% of its training data. We also found that current evaluation methods contain undesirable biases that a human evaluation is able to reveal. We suggest using human post-editing of GEC system outputs to analyze the amount of change required to reach native-level human performance on the task, and provide a dataset annotated with human post-edits and assessments of grammaticality, fluency and meaning preservation of GEC system outputs.

Grammatical Error Correction Based on Corpus

FCGEC: Fine-Grained Corpus for Chinese Grammatical Error Correction

Grammatical Error Correction: A Survey of the State of the Art

Automatic Grammatical Error Correction Based on Edit Operations Information.

A Simple but Effective Classification Model for Grammatical Error Correction.

TemplateGEC: Improving Grammatical Error Correction with Detection Template.

Grammatical Error Correction with Dependency Distance

Byte-Level Grammatical Error Correction Using Synthetic and Curated Corpora

Linguistic Rules-Based Corpus Generation for Native Chinese Grammatical Error Correction

Grammatical Error Correction for Code-Switched Sentences by Learners of English

From Spelling to Grammar: A New Framework for Chinese Grammatical Error Correction

Evaluation of really good grammatical error correction

Personalizing Grammatical Error Correction: Adaptation to Proficiency Level and L1

Detection-Correction Structure via General Language Model for Grammatical Error Correction

Evaluating Prompting Strategies for Grammatical Error Correction Based on Language Proficiency

A Syntax-Guided Grammatical Error Correction Model with Dependency Tree Correction

Factored Statistical Machine Translation for Grammatical Error Correction

Pillars of Grammatical Error Correction: Comprehensive Inspection Of Contemporary Approaches In The Era of Large Language Models

Adversarial Grammatical Error Correction

A Simple Yet Effective Corpus Construction Framework for Indonesian Grammatical Error Correction

Comparison of Grammatical Error Correction Using Back-Translation Models