Game Theory Analysis of Marketing Channel Conflict

AN Shi,XU Xing-jian,HAO Wen-jie

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:0367-6234.2005.10.030

2005-01-01

Abstract:In order to solve the marketing channel conflict more rational,this article advances a new way by making use of game theory.The conclusion is that profit difference is the basic source of channel conflict.and,the conflict is inevitable.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Using Game Strategy to Manage Channel Conflict Dilemmas

Jin Yan,Yingjie Wu,Haixia Qi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/icsssm.2007.4280268

2007-01-01

Abstract:Channel efficiency is one of the critical competitive advantages for modern companies. Channel conflict will affect the fluency of product distribution and the market efficiency seriously. The intensity and frequencies of the channel conflict has a direct effect on the determination of the success and failure of the channel. Based on Andrew J. DuBrin's systematic analysis model of conflict, the channel conflict process of a software company has been analyzed. In order to describe the specific features of channel conflict, we applied game theory and Chinese trust building perspective to analyze the conflict and trust building process of the business partners.
The Balance Analysis of the Channel Conflict

CHEN Shun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1006-723x.2012.02.021

2012-01-01

Abstract:In the information symmetry,alliance of channel members is a prisoner′s dilemma.The channel conflict is reflected by the balanced result of game.In the information asymmetry,due to the incentive incompatibilities between channel members and their respective core resources advantage,the cooperation between channel members becomes incredible,the optimal camera decision between channel members game is based on the amount of each other's overflow expectations and prior competitive contrast.At this time,the channel member alliance also becomes unstable.The channel conflict is reflected by the related balance outside of game strategy,or it is based on the specific related signal mechanism and balanced decisions.
The Understanding and Controlling of Channel Conflict

WANG Ying,LIU Yi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-148x.2005.07.014

2005-01-01

Abstract:In the field of channel management, conflict is a significant aspect that has attracted channel managers for many years. For those managers, how to understand, analyze and control conflicts has become a puzzle. Based on the concept and type of channel conflict, this paper manifests the reasons and main control patterns of channel conflict. Besides, it discusses a common conflict phenomenon, that is, sale beyond domain. It is expected to provide practical implication by guiding those enterprises to understand and manage conflict.
Study on Conflict in Marketing Channel of Dongfeng Commercial Car and Countermeasures

Wang Xiuli

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-5483.2006.04.022

2006-01-01

Abstract:The paper analysed the status of the marketing channel of Dongfeng commercial car,put forward some suggestions on solving the conflicts by the channel conflict theories.
Study of the horizontal competition of dual-channel retailer and traditional retailer with congestion negative effect of physical channel

Bing XU,Ping WANG,Bin ZHANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1006-0464.2018.01.017

2018-01-01

Abstract:Based on the Hotelling model,the game models were built to characterize the competition of one dual-channel retailer and one traditional retailer who are respectively located at two endpoints of linear market.The existence conditions and the equilibrium solutions for the competition equilibrium of two re-tailers were obtained under two situations such as differentiation pricing strategy and unified pricing strate-gy for products selling online and offline set by dual-channel retailer.The effectiveness of two pricing strat-egies and congestion negative effect affecting the competition equilibrium states were analyzed.Finally, some suggestions were proposed that the traditional retailer should speed up its transition and improve its service level,and the dual-channel retailer should make differentiation pricing for products selling online and offline and subdivide the market.
Pricing Games of Mixed Conventional and E-Commerce Distribution Channels

Qihui Lu,Nan Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cie.2012.09.018

IF: 7.18

2013-01-01

Computers & Industrial Engineering

Abstract:In this paper, a distribution system is studied, in which a supplier sells a common product through conventional (physical retailer) and e-commerce (e-tailers) channels. We examine two types of Stackelberg pricing games and one type of Nash pricing game in this dual-channel distribution system. We also analyze the effects of several key factors (i.e., the supplier’s pricing mode, game schemes, and efficiency of e-channel in relation to acceptance of channels) on the resulting prices as well as the profits for the supplier and the retailer, respectively. This paper is an effort to examine modeling competition in the multiple-channel environment from a pricing viewpoint. We find that channel acceptance plays a critical role in influencing equilibrium prices and profits in the dual-channel distribution system. When the customer acceptance of one channel exceeds a certain threshold, this channel cannibalizes all retail sales and dominates the distribution system. The supplier can make more profits by adopting a differential pricing strategy; on the contrary, the retailer prefers uniform pricing. Numerical analysis indicates that both the supplier and the retailer are worse off in the Nash game than in the Stackelberg games. The supplier prefers an e-channel with higher efficiency, whereas the physical retailer has to maintain higher channel acceptance to maintain its position in the distribution system.
Game theoretic analysis for advertising models in dual-channel supply chains

Ningning Wang,Ting Zhang,Xiaojun Fan,Xiaoxuan Zhu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00207543.2018.1540894

IF: 9.018

2018-11-01

International Journal of Production Research

Abstract:In the sharing economy, it is trendy that companies share advertising resources or investments. This paper develops game-theoretic models to discuss three advertising schemes in a dual-channel supply chain consisting of a manufacturer and two competing retailers. The first is brand advertising, i.e. the manufacturer advertises solely for its branded product. The second is emerging joint advertising, i.e. the manufacturer jointly advertises for the product and the online retailer, and the online retailer shares a part of the advertising costs. We propose a third model, the cost-sharing of brand advertising, i.e. the manufacturer advertises solely for the product, and the offline retailer shares a part of the advertising costs. The valuation enhancement effect of brand advertising, and the valuation enhancement and demand shifting effects of joint advertising are recognised and examined. The results show that whether retailers should cooperate with the manufacturer on advertising depends on the consumer initial preference for channels, and the potential scale and cost-efficiency of advertising. We find that joint advertising benefits participants at the expense of harming the offline retailer due to demand shifting effect, while the cost-sharing of brand advertising may benefit all due to the valuation enhancement effect.

engineering, manufacturing, industrial,operations research & management science
A Study of the Joint Advertising Channels

Ming LEI,Shuguang SUN,Dan YANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4236/jssm.2009.24050

2009-01-01

Journal of Service Science and Management

Abstract:The study of joint advertising channels decision-making is a very difficult issue. It mainly focuses on ads investment game between a manufacturer and a retailer in a vertical supply chain. With the rise of the game theory, scholars have been starting to investigate this issue in the frame of game theory in recent years. The paper improves the existing models and introduces single-period and multi-period modified models. The paper obtains the closed-form solutions to the single-period model and the simulation results of the multi-period model. We also examine the implications of these results and obtain some insights into the real practice.
Channel structure selection in a competitive supply chain under consideration of marketing effort strategy

Mingxia Li,Kebing Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00500-022-07468-z

IF: 3.732

2022-09-09

Soft Computing

Abstract:We study the optimal decisions of a supplier in terms of channel structure selection and marketing effort strategy when facing a competitor offering substitutable products. By employing game theoretic models for different retail competition scenarios, we show that equilibrium channel structures are primarily determined by the intensity of retail competition along with the marketing effort level. Channel structure selection and marketing effort strategy are interdependent and interactive. Our results show that the supplier has an incentive to make marketing effort and sell products directly to consumers in most cases. When the retail competition becomes fiercer, the supplier can benefit from selecting a distribution strategy based on customers' sensitivity to the supplier's marketing effort. In contrast, the supplier selling products through the downstream retailer will not make marketing effort under certain market conditions (e.g., low competition and high customer sensitivity to the supplier's effort performance), while the competitor adopts the direct-sales strategy. Generally, the supplier will prefer making marketing effort relative to undertaking product distribution. Finally, we also examine the strategic effects of channel structure selection and marketing effort decisions on the competitor's profit in the retail competition market.

computer science, artificial intelligence, interdisciplinary applications
“The Lifecycle Viewpoint” of the Management of Channel Conflict-Opportunism and Its Governance Mechanism

Gao Weihe,Huang Pei,Wang Zhenguo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2006.03.006

2006-01-01

Abstract:The management of channel conflict is one of the hot top- ics of marketing research. Unfortunately, however, the management of channel conflicts is all result-oriented. Not only the management often neglects the analysis of the antecedent cause of channel conflict, but also lack the overall idea of channel governance. The author points out that the antecedent causes of conflict is opportunism, and this calls for the overall process management of conflict. The opportunism-based idea of conflict governance argues that it should have the partner-se- lection during the beginning, decide the value of all channel members and keep the open-minded relationship. Based on this, we can realize the harmony of channel relationship. What’s more, the author pave the way for channel conflict governance through the analysis of China channel conflict cases.
Study on Conflict in Marketing Channel of Dongfeng Peugeot and Countermeasures

Xiuli Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-5483.2015.04.016

2015-01-01

Abstract:The current situation of Dongfeng Peugeot marketing channel management was analyzed. In view of the three kinds of channel conflict forms and the cause of formation, the corresponding counter-measures for the prevention of channel conflict and the fusion based on the O2O were put forward.
Some game theoretic marketing attribution models

Elisenda Molina,Juan Tejada,Tom Weiss

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2012.00812

2020-11-02

Abstract:In this paper, we propose and analyse two game theoretical models useful to design marketing channels attribution mechanisms based on cooperative TU games and bankruptcy problems, respectively. First, we analyse the Sum Game, a coalitional game introduced by Morales (2016). We extend the ideas introduced in Zhao et al. (2018) and Cano-Berlanga et al. (2017) to the case in which the order and the repetition of channels on the paths to conversion are taken into account. In all studied cases, the Shapley value is proposed as the attribution mechanism. Second, a bankruptcy problem approach is proposed, and a similar analysis is developed relying on the Constrained Equal Loss (CEL) and Proportional (PROP) rules as attribution mechanisms. In particular, it is relevant to note that the class of attribution bankruptcy problems is a proper subclass of bankruptcy problems.

Theoretical Economics,Optimization and Control
A Game Theoretical Study of Cooperative Advertising with Multiple Retailers in A Distribution Channel

Jihua Zhang,Jinxing Xie

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11518-011-5165-y

2012-01-01

Abstract:Extant studies of cooperative advertising mainly consider a single-manufacturer-single-retailer channel structure. This can provide limited insights, because a manufacturer, in real practices, usually deals with multiple retailers simultaneously. In order to examine the impact of the retailer's multiplicity on channel members' decisions and on total channel efficiencies, this paper develops a multiple-retailer model. In this model, the manufacturer and the retailers play a Stackelberg game to make the optimal advertising decisions. Based on the quantitative results, it is observed that: 1) When there are multiple symmetric retailers, as the number of retailers scales up, the manufacturer's national advertising investment contributes increasingly to add to channel members' profits in equilibrium, but the total channel efficiency deteriorates quickly and converges down to a certain value; 2) When there are multiple asymmetric retailers, the distribution channel suffers from the manufacturer's uniform participation strategy due to the retailer's free-riding, and benefits with the manufacturer's retailer-specific participation strategy. This study derives equilibrium solutions in closed form for all games considered and measures explicitly the gains/losses of channel efficiencies under different game settings.
Consumer Choice, Firm Performance and Channel Coordination in a Dual-Channel Distribution System

Wei Song,Renwen Wang,Yelin Fu,Xiaobao Peng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4236/ajor.2014.44021

2014-01-01

American Journal of Operations Research

Abstract:The expanding role of the Internet in consumer purchasing activities has created substantial new opportunities accessing to end-consumers. More and more manufacturers are beginning to sell products to potential consumers directly online while continuing to sell through the traditional brick-and-mortar retailers, a phenomenon leading to intense channel competition and conflicts. Using game theory, this research examines the effect of market segments, consumer choice and the acceptance of direct online channels on firm performance and the whole system’s profit. The analysis indicates that the addition of direct online channel does not necessarily harm the incumbent retailers. A win-win zone is proposed, in which both the manufacturer and the retailer benefit from the encroachment.
Pricing Game Models of Hybrid Channel Supply Chain: A Strategic Consumer Behavior Perspective

Xuelong Zhang,Yufei Li,Jianhua Zhu,Xuequan Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/jtaer18030060

2023-07-06

Journal of theoretical and applied electronic commerce research

Abstract:The current sales model combining online and offline channels meets the diverse requirements of consumers. However, consumers’ inter-channel switching behavior and strategic behavior also pose significant challenges to pricing decisions in the hybrid channel. Using game theory and consumer utility theory, a retailer-driven pricing model is developed to study the optimal pricing problem for each channel in a mixed-channel supply chain considering the characteristics of channel competition and the waiting behavior of strategic consumers. Study results show there is a negative correlation between the proportion of strategic consumers and the optimal pricing and profit of each channel, and as the proportion of strategic consumers rises, the optimal pricing and profit of manufacturers and retailers all trend downward. Incorporating strategic consumers into the pricing model will assist the supply chain in elucidating the behavior of consumer heterogeneity during various decision-making periods and in making reasonable pricing decisions. Effective guiding strategies, such as pre-discount and purchase restrictions, can reduce the profit loss caused by strategic consumer behavior. The optimal combination of pre-announcement discount and strategic consumer ratio can generate the greatest profit for retailers and the supply chain.

business
The Complexity Analysis in Dual-Channel Supply Chain Based on Fairness Concern and Different Business Objectives

Li Qiu-xiang,Zhang Yu-hao,Huang Yi-min

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1155/2018/4752765

IF: 2.3

2018-01-01

Complexity

Abstract:We study a dual-channel supply chain which consists of one dual-channel manufacturer and one traditional retailer considering fairness concern. The manufacturer takes the market share as one of its business objectives in the competition game. We are devoted to establishing a vertical Nash game model and analyzing the price evolution of the model via the method of complexity theory and take adaptive adjustment control method to control the system’s chaotic state. The results show that an excessive price adjustment speed will hurt the system’s stability as well as profit of the supply chain. A high level fair caring for retailer will push the system to fall into chaos earlier, while a higher level fair caring for manufacturer will enlarge the stability region of the system. Setting the different objectives by the manufacturer will cause drastic competition in dual-channel supply chain. The research of this paper is of great significance to the decision-makers’ price decision and supply chain operation management.

mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,multidisciplinary sciences
Modeling Channel Coordination in Advertising and Pricing

Jinxing Xie,Jerry C. Wei

2007-01-01

Abstract:Cooperative (co-op) advertising plays a significant role in marketing programs and makes up the majority of promotional budgets for both manufacturers and retailers. Nevertheless, most studies to date on co-op advertising have assumed that the market demand is only influenced by the advertising level and not by the retail price. This paper addresses channel coordination seeking optimal co-op advertising strategies and equilibrium pricing in a two-member distribution channel. We develop and compare two coordination models: a non-cooperative, leader-follower game and a cooperative game. We develop theorems and insights from the comparison of these models. The cooperative model achieves better coordination and generates a higher channel extra-profit than the non-cooperative model.
A Game Model On The Profit Distributive Of Manufacturer-Retailer Supply Chain Alliance

Jiong Meng,Xiaowo Tang,Debing Ni

2008-01-01

Abstract:From the perspective of the corporate social responsibilities (CSR)-- the product safety, and its influence on the consumers, applying the basic idea of game theory, this paper studies on profit distributive model of manufacturer-retail- er supply chain alliance. The results show that a manufacturer forming a supply chain alliance with retailers is the unique Nash equilibrium of the game. The study will provide important guidance to the marketing decision for firms and retailers.
Game Analysis on Applicability of Relationship Marketing——An Expanded Model of Hotelling

杜巍,叶岑,梁琛

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-2848.2003.05.015

2003-01-01

Abstract:Nowadays when conventional marketing theories and their practical results are fully questionable, the applicability of relationship marketing has become a topic demanding urgent concern and prompt solution. In perspective of industrial competition and with the game theory and the expanded hotelling model, this paper makes an in-depth and careful analysis on the applicability of relationship marketing activities under market competition. And thus it obtains the functional models of all kinds of equilibrium conditions under competitive market equilibrium, and accordingly reaching some conclusions and viewpoints on the issue concerned.
Dynamic Game Analysis on Cooperative Advertising Strategy in a Manufacturer-Led Supply Chain with Risk Aversion

Jia Liu,Cuixia Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/math11030512

IF: 2.4

2023-01-19

Mathematics

Abstract:This paper considers a dynamic Stackelberg game model for a manufacturer-led supply chain with risk aversion. Cooperative advertising strategy is applied to the marketing decisions of supply chain participants. Based on Stackelberg game and system dynamic theory, the game and complex dynamical behaviors are studied through the use of several methods, such as the stability region of the system, bifurcation diagram, attractor diagram, and the largest Lyapunov exponent diagram. The expected utilities of participants are given and compared by numerical simulation. The results illustrate that a series of variations in adjustment speed of advertising expenditure, participation rate of local advertising expenditure by manufacturer, risk tolerance levels, and the effect coefficient of advertising expenditure may cause a loss of stability to the system and evolve into chaos. Meanwhile, the Nash equilibrium point and the expected utility of the manufacturer and retailer will change greatly. The parameter control method is further applied to control the chaos phenomenon of the system effectively. By means of analyzing the impact of relevant factors on the game model, the manufacturer and retailer can make optimal strategy decisions in the supply chain competition. The findings of this study mainly include the following three aspects. Firstly, for market stability and maximizing revenue, the manufacturer adjusts the participation rate appropriately, avoiding too high or too low values. Secondly, the manufacturer will try to reduce their own risk tolerance level for the economic revenue, and the retailer appropriately adjust the risk tolerance level to adapt to their own development according to their own enterprise strategy. Finally, both the manufacturer and retailer reduce their own effect coefficients of advertising expenditure. Meanwhile, they will attempt to increase their opponent's effect coefficient to gain the most revenue. The research results of this study can provide important reference for the advertising expenditure decision and revenue maximization of participants in the context of risk aversion.

mathematics

Game Theory Analysis of Marketing Channel Conflict

Using Game Strategy to Manage Channel Conflict Dilemmas

The Balance Analysis of the Channel Conflict

The Understanding and Controlling of Channel Conflict

Study on Conflict in Marketing Channel of Dongfeng Commercial Car and Countermeasures

Study of the horizontal competition of dual-channel retailer and traditional retailer with congestion negative effect of physical channel

Pricing Games of Mixed Conventional and E-Commerce Distribution Channels

Game theoretic analysis for advertising models in dual-channel supply chains

A Study of the Joint Advertising Channels

Channel structure selection in a competitive supply chain under consideration of marketing effort strategy

“The Lifecycle Viewpoint” of the Management of Channel Conflict-Opportunism and Its Governance Mechanism

Study on Conflict in Marketing Channel of Dongfeng Peugeot and Countermeasures

Some game theoretic marketing attribution models

A Game Theoretical Study of Cooperative Advertising with Multiple Retailers in A Distribution Channel

Consumer Choice, Firm Performance and Channel Coordination in a Dual-Channel Distribution System

Pricing Game Models of Hybrid Channel Supply Chain: A Strategic Consumer Behavior Perspective

The Complexity Analysis in Dual-Channel Supply Chain Based on Fairness Concern and Different Business Objectives

Modeling Channel Coordination in Advertising and Pricing

A Game Model On The Profit Distributive Of Manufacturer-Retailer Supply Chain Alliance

Game Analysis on Applicability of Relationship Marketing——An Expanded Model of Hotelling

Dynamic Game Analysis on Cooperative Advertising Strategy in a Manufacturer-Led Supply Chain with Risk Aversion