Abstract:Code clones are identical or similar code in software projects. On one hand, developers clone code to achieve higher productivity and thus clones inherently exist; on the other hand, code clones demand extra effort to maintain the consistency between clone instances and may introduce bugs, and thus are often considered harmful for software maintenance and quality. We believe that not all code clones have the same level of harmfulness. A systematic way of assessing the harmfulness level of cloned code would facilitate informed decisions on how to deal with clones. We propose a model for clone harmfulness level assessment with four quantitative indicators that can be extracted from the evolution history of the clones. Specifically, we gather information, such as code clone changes and bugfixes related to clone divergence and re-synchronization, to find objective evidence that a clone harms the software quality or brings potential risks even if no bugs are found. The assessment model consists of four harmfulness levels of clones determined by the four indicators. We also derive three harmfulness factors from the intrinsic properties of clones that potentially affect the harmfulness of clones. We conduct a large-scale empirical study with five open-source and three industry systems and find that 61.0-84.7% of the clones are not harmful in terms of consistent maintenance overhead. We find evidence in the evolution history that several factors, such as spread of clone instances, number of clone instances, and number of developers, have non-trivial correlation with clone harmfulness levels. We also propose six counter measures for clone harmfulness mitigation based on the observation of the harmfulness factors, and have collected useful feedback from industrial software architects and senior developers through an interview meeting.

Research on code clone analysis approach

Code Clone Detection: A Literature Review

Detecting Differences Across Multiple Instances of Code Clones

Code Clone Detection Method for Large-Scale Source Code

Do Code Clones Matter?

The Development and Prospect of Code Clone

Clone Detection on Large Scala Codebases

Detection of clone sequences and classes using AST

XIAO: Tuning Code Clones at Hands of Engineers in Practice

Clonepedia: Summarizing Code Clones by Common Syntactic Context for Software Maintenance

Grouping-Based Incremental Clone Detection Method

Automatic Refactoring Method of Cloned Code Using Abstract Syntax Tree and Static Analysis

A novel code representation for detecting Java code clones using high-level and abstract compiled code representations

Clone-Seeker: Effective Code Clone Search Using Annotations

SCDetector

Transferring Code-Clone Detection and Analysis to Practice

Cloning Practices: Why Developers Clone and What Can Be Changed

DroidCC: A Scalable Clone Detection Approach for Android Applications to Detect Similarity at Source Code Level.

DCCD: an Efficient and Scalable Distributed Code Clone Detection Technique for Big Code

Software Vulnerability Code Clone Detection Method Based on Characteristic Metrics

Assessing Code Clone Harmfulness: Indicators, Factors, and Counter Measures.