Abstract:Digital elevation models (DEMs) are the basic data of science and engineering technology research. SRTM and ASTER GDEM are currently widely used global DEMs, and TanDEM-X DEM, released in 2016, has attracted users' attention due to its unprecedented accuracy. These global datasets are often used for local applications and the quality of DEMs affects the results of applications. Many researchers have assessed and compared the quality of global DEMs on a local scale. To provide some additional insights on quality assessment of 12- and 30-m resolution TanDEM-X DEMs, 30-m resolution ASTER GDEM and 30-m resolution SRTM, this study assessed differences' performance in relation to not only geographical features but also the ways in which DEMs have been created on selected Chinese sites, taking ICESat/GLAS points with 14-cm absolute vertical accuracy but size of 70-m diameter and 12-m resolution TanDEM-X DEM with less than 10-m absolute vertical accuracy as the reference data for comprehensive quality evaluation. When comparing the three 30-m DEMs with the reference DEM, an improved Least Z-Difference (LZD) method was applied for co-registration between models, and Quantile-Quantile (Q-Q) plot was used to identify if the DEM errors follow a normal distribution to help choose proper statistical indicators accordingly. The results show that: (1) TanDEM-X DEMs have the best overall quality, followed by SRTM. ASTER GDEM has the worst quality. The 12-m TanDEM-X DEM has significant advantages in describing terrain details. (2) The quality of DEM has a strong relationship with slope, aspect and land cover. However, the relationship between aspect and vertical quality weakens after data co-registration. The quality of DEMs gets higher with the increasing number of images used in the fusion process. The quality in where slopes opposite to the radar beam is the worst for SRTM, which could provide a new perspective for quality assessment of SRTM and other DEMs whose incidence angle files are available. (3) Systematic deviations can reduce the vertical quality of DEM. The differences have non-normal distribution even after co-registration. For researchers who want to know the quality of a DEM in order to use it in further applications, they should pay more attention to the terrain factors and land cover in their study areas and the ways in which the DEM has been created.

DEM Data Quality Detecting Based on Spatial Index

Research on the Analysis and Statistic of Geographical Conditions Based on the Strategy of "grid Index + MapReduce"

A Precision Evaluation Index System for Remote Sensing Data Sampling Based on Hexagonal Discrete Grids

Quality Assessment of TanDEM-X DEMs, SRTM and ASTER GDEM on Selected Chinese Sites

A Rapid and High-Precision Mountain Vertex Extraction Method Based on Hotspot Analysis Clustering and Improved Eight-Connected Extraction Algorithms for Digital Elevation Models

Quality Assessment Of Three Digital Elevation Models With 30 M Resolution By Taking 12 M Tandem-X Dem As Reference

Detection of terrain feature points from digital elevation models using contour context

Parallel Calculation and Efficiency Analysis for Neighborhood Statistic Algorithm in Digital Terrain Analysis

Study on Generation Technique of High Quality Contour Lines Based on Grid DEM

Peak Extraction and Classification from Digital Elevation Models Based on the Relationship Between Morphological Characteristics and Spatial Position

Algorithm for Generating Regular Grid DTM Based on the Spatial Index

Evaluating Spatial Data Quality in GIS Database

DEM-based topographic change detection considering the spatial distribution of errors

A new method of generating grid DEM from contour lines

Accuracy Assessment of High-Resolution Globally Available Open-Source DEMs Using ICESat/GLAS over Mountainous Areas, A Case Study in Yunnan Province, China

An Index and Retrieval Method of Spatial Data Based on GeoSOT Global Discrete Grid System

Study on quality assessment of multi-source and multi-scale images in disaster prevention and relief

An Efficient Splicing and Rapid Extraction of Spatial Data Method Based on Global Subdivsion

Construction of high-precision DEMs for urban plots

Assessing Data Quality for Geographical Information System Databases

Measuring Data Quality of Geoscience Datasets Using Data Mining Techniques