Analysis and Application of Bazant's Size Effect Laws

李勇,郑建军,金贤玉

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-3550.2003.02.015

2003-01-01

Abstract:Two size effect models,energy releasebased size effect law and unified size effect law,presented by Bazant are discussed in the present paper.By analyzing and comparing the two models,it is concluded that the energy releasebased size effect law is better applicable to concrete structures.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

New Statistical Quantification Method for the Size Effect Behavior of Rock Mass Using Compressive Strength As an Example

Man Huang,Dan Liu,Chenjie Hong,Zhigang Tao,Shigui Du,Yixiao Huang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1061/(asce)gm.1943-5622.0002579

IF: 3.918

2022-01-01

International Journal of Geomechanics

Abstract:The statistical law on mechanical parameters of rock mass with size is the key to the study of the size effect. Since the existing statistical methods of the size effect only consider the continuity of the size but not the difference between the samples of each size, a new statistical method that considers single size and multisize is proposed. Based on the proposed method, the true representative elementary volume (TREV) value is used to determine the size effect stability threshold. Combined with the analysis of the three major size effect theories, the unified size effect law model and variation index k are proposed. The results are validated by statistical test data on the uniaxial compressive strength (UCS) obtained in realistic failure process analysis (RFPA) numerical test and from other works, which proves that the proposed method can reflect the variation law of UCS value with size and provide a basis for theoretical research on the size effect in mechanical behavior.
Numerical analysis of concrete strength size effect on meso-level

HUANG Hai-yan,YANG Guan-ying,SHEN Chao-ming,WANG Su-rui,ZHANG Yi-duo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-3550.2007.04.005

2007-01-01

Abstract:Firstly using the concrete meso-model to carry on the numerical analysis to the axial tensile specimen,then,carrying on the comparative analysis in 1:8 size scope to the axial tensile specimen strength size effect.The analysis indicated that,the specimen strength increases along with the specimen size reduces.The Bazant size effect law and the Carpinteri size effect law all can simulate the size effect of the concrete material well,regarding the tensile strength size effect phenomenon,the Carpinteri multiple fractal size effect law is more accurate.
Effect of Aggregate on Cracking Behaviours of Concrete in Mesoscopic Modeling

Yuan Zheng Sun Tao,Shui Fu Chen,Le Sheng Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/amr.243-249.971

2011-01-01

Advanced Materials Research

Abstract:This paper aims to study the influence of aggregate shape and size on the tensile strength, compressive strength and fracture energy in mesoscopic modeling of concrete. For this purpose, several numerical models under three loading cases, uniaxial tension, uniaxial compression and bending resistance test are analyzed utilizing the software ABAQUS/Explicit. The mechanical responses and cracking behaviors well match the realistic situations of experiments. Various stress-strain curves and fracture patterns are presented and compared, which indicate that the aggregate size has very small effect on the tensile strength, compressive strength and fracture energy, and the effect of aggregate shape is a little more significant than that of the size.
Research of Loading Effects of Blast in Air

SHENG Li,GUO Yu-rong,XIAO Yan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-7304.2006.02.001

2006-01-01

Abstract:With the increase of terroristic attacks,blasting has posed a severe threat on lives and properties,The blast loading effects on structures has been gradually considered in structural designs. Experiments and numerical simulations on explosion have been carried out and mechanism of blast waves and calculation of blast loading have been proposed by many researchers.This paper presents the mechanism of blast waves and the interior and exterior loading effects on structures caused by blast.The existing literature and author's latest research is proposed and future research issues on blast loading calculation are pointed out for the purpose of using blast load in practical structural design.
Size Effect for Normal Strength Concrete in Uniaxial Tension

李庆斌,尹玉先

2012-01-01

Abstract:This paper presents a new size effect model for normal strength concrete subjected to uniaxial tension. The model is based on two extremes, sand cement paste in uniaxial tension and a sand-cement-paste/rock interface in uniaxial tension. Uniaxial tension tests with normal strength concrete measuring the tensile strength of normal strength concrete specimens with different geometrical shapes and different ratios of the aggregate size to the characteristic dimension of the concrete specimen show a significant size effect. The theoretical size effect law prediction agrees well with the experimental data.
A Practical Discrete Sizing Optimization Methodology for the Design of High-Rise Concrete Buildings

Haopeng Lou,Zhibin Xiao,Yinyuan Wan,Fengling Jin,Boqing Gao,Chao Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/ec-08-2021-0473

2022-01-01

Engineering Computations

Abstract:Purpose In this article, a practical design methodology is proposed for discrete sizing optimization of high-rise concrete buildings with a focus on large-scale and real-life structures. Design/methodology/approach This framework relies on a computationally efficient approximation of the constraint and objective functions using a radial basis function model with a linear tail, also called the combined response surface methodology (RSM) in this article. Considering both the code-stipulated constraints and other construction requirements, three sub-optimization problems were constructed based on the relaxation model of the original problem, and then the structural weight could be automatically minimized under multiple constraints and loading scenarios. After modulization, the obtained results could meet the discretization requirements. By integrating the commercially available ETABS, a dedicated optimization software program with an independent interface was developed and details for practical software development were also presented in this paper. Findings The proposed framework was used to optimize different high-rise concrete buildings, and case studies showed that material usage could be saved by up to 12.8% compared to the conventional design, and the over-limit constraints could be adjusted, which proved the feasibility and effectiveness. Originality/value This methodology can therefore be applied by engineers to explore the optimal distribution of dimensions for high-rise buildings and to reduce material usage for a more sustainable design.
Experimental Description of Size Effect for Brittle Materials Using Specimens with Fixed Crack Length

张彤,孟庆元,杜善义

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-4750.2001.05.017

2001-01-01

Abstract:Due to the existence of various micro-defects in brittle or quasi-brittle materials, the mechanical behavior, such as the nominal failure stress, stiffness and fracture toughness etc., varies with the dimension of specimens. This is defined as the size effect of such materials. In general, the Bazant size effect law is established experimentally using a series of similar specimens. In this paper, a new experimental procedure by which the fracture toughness and effective fracture process zone length are measured using the specimens with fixed crack length is proposed, and the associated formulas are also presented. Under the condition that identical brittleness numbers must be ensured for both the proposed and commonly-used similar specimen method, relatively small specimens can be used under laboratory conditions. It is shown that and good agreement is reached in comparison with the results of the commonly-used similar specimen method.
Stress-Strain Behavior of Cementitious Materials with Different Sizes

Jikai Zhou,Pingping Qian,Xudong Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1155/2014/919154

2014-01-01

Abstract:The size dependence of flexural properties of cement mortar and concrete beams is investigated. Bazant’s size effect law and modified size effect law by Kim and Eo give a very good fit to the flexural strength of both cement mortar and concrete. As observed in the test results, a strong size effect in flexural strength is found in cement mortar than in concrete. A modification has been suggested to Li’s equation for describing the stress-strain curve of cement mortar and concrete by incorporating two different correction factors, the factors contained in the modified equation being established empirically as a function of specimen size. A comparison of the predictions of this equation with test data generated in this study shows good agreement.
Numerical and theoretical investigation on the size effect of concrete compressive strength considering the maximum aggregate size

Liu Jin,Wenxuan Yu,Dong Li,Xiuli Du

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmecsci.2020.106130

IF: 7.3

2021-02-01

International Journal of Mechanical Sciences

Abstract:The aggregate size plays an important role in the nonlinear mechanical behaviour of concrete, which is strongly related to the size effect. In this study, the meso-mechanical modelling method has been established based on the continuous grading aggregate model to simulate the uniaxial compressive failure behaviour under quasi-static load of concrete square samples having different side lengths, maximum aggregate sizes (MAS) and concrete strength grades. The numerical results demonstrated that the MAS affected the crack propagation form in the internal components of concrete and the nominal compressive strength decreased with the increasing MAS; the increasing MAS could enhance the sensitivity of strength-to-structural size and make the size effect more obvious. In addition to the numerical analysis, a modified Type-2 size effect law considering the MAS for the nominal compressive strength has been proposed from theoretical perspective, which makes it possible to quantitatively predict the size effect behaviour of compressive strength. Mesoscopic simulation results and some experimental results have validated the modified Type-2 size effect law.

engineering, mechanical,mechanics
Size Effects on Mechanical Properties of Micro/Nano Structures

Amir Musa Abazari,Seyed Mohsen Safavi,Ghader Rezazadeh,Luis Guillermo Villanueva

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1508.01322

2015-08-06

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

Abstract:Experiments on Micro- and Nano-mechanical systems (M/NEMS) have shown that their behavior upon bending loads departs in many cases from the classical predictions using Euler-Bernoulli theory and Hooke law. This anomalous response has usually been seen as a dependence of the material properties with the size of the structure, in particular thickness. A theoretical model that allows for quantitative understanding and prediction of this size effect is important for the design of M/NEMS. In this paper, we summarize and analyze the five theories that can be found in the literature: Grain Boundary Theory (GBT), Surface Stress Theory (SST), Residual Stress Theory (RST), Couple Stress Theory (CST) and Surface Elasticity Theory (SET). By comparing these theories with experimental data we propose a simplified model combination of CST and SET that properly fits all considered cases, therefore delivering a simple (two parameters) model that can be used to predict the mechanical properties at the nanoscale.
A Mesoscopic Approach for the Size Effect on Fracture Energy of Concrete

Jun Zheng

IF: 2.4

2001-01-01

Journal of Hydraulic Engineering

Abstract:A mesoscopic approach for the size effect on fracture energy of concrete is presented. Based on the wall effect on mesostructure of concrete, the fractal dimension of the macro crack in a concrete specimen is determined, which is found to change with the distance from the specimen boundaries. To calculate the length of the main macro crack with variable fractal dimension, a differential relationship between the fractal length of a curve and the corresponding Euclidian length is put forward by extending the definition of the fractal length of a curve. By applying the principle of energy equivalence, the nominal fracture energy of concrete is expressed in terms of the fractal fracture energy, the fractal dimension, some mesostructural dimensions and the cross sectional dimension of the specimen. A further theoretical analysis reveals that the basic mechanical characteristics of the nominal fracture energy agree with the observed macroscopic experimental phenomena of concrete. The theoretical prediction is compared with experiment data to confirm the effectiveness of the approach.
Fractal size effect model on fracture energy of concrete

Huang Haiyan,Lu Hongqin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1673-4807.2010.04.005

2010-01-01

Abstract:A fractal approach for the size effect on fracture energy of concrete was presented.Based on size effect analysis and mesoscopic structure character of material,a fractal size effect law(FSEL) of concrete fracture energy was proposed simultaneously.Comparison between the FSEL and the multi-fractal scaling law(MSFL) was done by using a serial experimental data.The analysis results show the FSEL is feasible and reliable.
Analytical and Numerical Study of the Size Effect on the Failure Response of Hierarchical Structures

Z. Chen,Y. Gan,J. F. Labuz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1615/intjmultcompeng.v6.i4.50

2008-01-01

International Journal for Multiscale Computational Engineering

Abstract:Recent interests in developing bio-inspired structures necessitate a better understanding of the onset and evolution of failure in hierarchical structures. With the use of different constitutive models, analytical and numerical studies are performed to explore the size effect on the structural failure response of bar members in a parallel arrangement. It is found from the analytical and numerical results that the shorter the member, the more likely for stable softening to occur if there is only one member in the system, and that the larger the member number in the system, the more energy dissipation is associated with the postlimit regime.
Essential Difference and Design Application of Boundary Effect Model and Size Effect Model

李庆斌,吴智敏,管俊峰

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13243/j.cnki.slxb.20161175

2017-01-01

Abstract:A comparative study of the essential difference,design,and application of boundary effect model (BEM) and size effect model (SEM) was conducted.SEM applies the four different multi-parameter empirical equations to the different ratio of initial crack length and specimen depth α.SEM is limited to a data-fitting function.BEM model involves the use of a unique analytical solution.On one hand,BEM can determine the material parameters-fracture toughness KIC and tensile strength f through the fitting of experimental data.On the other hand,it can establish a complete designed curve that describes the overall fracture of structure based on the identified KIC and f.The effect on three fracture controlled model (f-controlled,KIC-controlled and quasi-brittle fracture) were systematically calculated and analyzed from specimen to structure (size W=25-25000mm).The results show that linear elastic fracture mechanics (LEFM) applies for very long crack and very large structures,and there is no further need for size effect study.The size effect model is only relevant when the crack tip is close to either the front or back boundaries.The so-called "size effect" is only a special case of boundary effect.Based on the results of fracture tests (the specimen size W is 40,93,215 and 500 mm,and the ratio of initial crack length and specimen depth α is 0,0.02,0.075,0.15 and 0.3),the different combination conditions of tested data that BEM systematically studied are adopted to determine the influence law of KIC and f.The results are shown that,values are basically consistent to KIC and f,which have been determined by BEM,when the test data reaches a certain amount and one or two groups of data are removed from the overall data,either the specimens have the different W with same α=a0/W,or the same W but different α=a0/W.The studied results of this paper gave a new ideal to solve the problem that the material parameters cannot be accurately obtained using small size specimen,as well as the problem on predicting the actual structure fracture by using the material parameters.
Structural size effect in the mode I and mixed mode I/II fracture of strain-hardening cementitious composites (SHCC)

Qingmin Wang,Qinghua Li,Xing Yin,Shilang Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsolstr.2023.112628

IF: 3.667

2023-12-23

International Journal of Solids and Structures

Abstract:The size effect in the fracture of solids represents a highly critical issue with a prolonged history of research. The size effect of traditional quasi-brittle materials can already be well described through the size effect model. However, there is still a lack of research on the size effect of strain-hardening cementitious composites (SHCC), a special type of fibre-reinforced concrete with macro-scale strain-hardening behaviour after first cracking. Being distinct from traditional quasi-brittle materials with softening nature, SHCC is thus expected to behave differently in terms of size effect. In this research, the structural size effect problem of SHCC is comprehensively studied by experimental investigation and theoretical analysis. Geometrically similar notched three-point bending specimens were tested in mode I and mixed mode I/II fracture condition. The whole-process of failure and matrix cracking zone around the main crack was captured with high resolution by digital image correlation technology. Experimental results showed that apparent fracture energy, nominal strength, structural ductility and fracture resistance curve are all structural size-dependent. The apparent fracture energy was shown to arise with specimen size within the tested range. This is related to large-scale pseudo yielding, i.e. enlargement of matrix cracking zone (like the yielding zone in metals) with increasing structural size. It thus provides an indirect method for the estimation of cohesive fracture energy of single crack with constitutive nature. Due to the scaled matrix cracking zone, an intermediate asymptote exists in the size effect curve of nominal strength, in addition to the plastic and LEFM asymptotes in the Bažant original size effect law. This resembles the recent finding of intermediate asymptote in plastic-hardening metal( Dönmez et al. 2023 ). The size-dependence of R-curve was also examined. Though size-dependent, the equivalent LEFM-based R-curves are shown to have three common stages reflecting different cracking processes. Based on experimental results, the size effect of fracture energy and nominal strength are finally modelled theoretically in the Bažant's framework of equivalence between energy release and fracture resistance.

mechanics
Effects of Reinforcement Bar on Shrinkage Stress of Concrete

王纪跃,钱晓倩

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-3550.2004.12.001

2004-01-01

Abstract:The effect of on the shrinkage stresses of concrete is studied.A new model is proposed for describing the restraining relationship.Based on the incremental analysis,the expression of the Interior Coefficient of Reinforcement,ICR,(that is,the shrinkage stress increment of the reinforced concrete member compared to that of the plane concrete member) is established.The research shows that the ICR is linearly increased with the ratio,while its slope is determined by the magnitude of the exterior constraints.The slope decreases with the increase of magnitude of the exterior constraints.The current calculation method for shrinkage stress is based on the reinforcement concrete body.It neglects the interior restraint effect of the reinforcement,while unreasonably looks the interior restraint of the as that of the aggregates.Those will under-estimate the actual shrinkage stress of concrete by 10%～40%.
Experimental Study on the Size Effect on the Equation of State of Concretes under Shock Loading

Mei Li,Jian Cui,Yanchao Shi,Baijian Tang,Xin Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dt.2023.06.014

IF: 4.035

2024-01-01

Defence Technology

Abstract:Adopting the classical theory of hydrocodes, the constitutive relations of concretes are separated into an equation of state (EoS) which describes the volumetric behavior of concrete material and a strength model which depicts the shear properties of concrete. The experiments on the EoS of concrete is always challenging due to the technical difficulties and equipment limitations, especially for the specimen size effect on the EoS. Although some researchers investigate the shock properties of concretes by fly-plate impact tests, the specimens used in their tests are usually in one size. In this paper, the fly-plate impact tests on concrete specimens with different sizes are performed to investigate the size effect on the shock properties of concrete materials. The mechanical background of the size effect on the shock properties are revealed, which is related to the lateral rarefaction effect and the deviatoric stress produced in the specimen. According to the tests results, the modified EoS considering the size effect on the shock properties of concrete are proposed, which the bulk modulus of concrete is unpredicted by up to 20% if size effects are not accounted for.
Size Effects of Concrete Gravity Dams Based on XFEM Analyses

SHI Jie,LI Qingbin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.16511/j.cnki.qhdxxb.2017.25.002

2017-01-01

Abstract:Similarity model test results cannot be simply converted to the prototype without consideration of the size effect.The extended finite element method(XFEM)was used to analyze the failure mechanism and overall structure strength of a type of prenotched gravity dam.The size effect was investigated by analyzing the nominal strength of geometrically similar prenotched gravity dams with various sizes.The nominal strength and failure mechanism were analyzed for two sets of models with an extra centrifugal force and a self-weight force.The results show that the structural strength in the centrifugal models decreases exponentially and tends to be stable for larger sizes, while in gravitational models the strength decreases exponentially up to a critical height and then increases gradually due the self-weight contribution.The relative length of the fracture process zone is an intrinsic factor while the self-weight stress is an external loading factor for the effect of size on the structural strength.
Size Effect On Fatigue In Bending Of Concrete

J Zhang,Vc Li,H Stang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0899-1561(2001)13:6(446)

IF: 3.2

2001-01-01

Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering

Abstract:This paper presents a semianalytical method to predict fatigue behavior in flexure of concrete in the case of maximum flexural moment larger than that of the first crack moment based on force equilibrium in the critical cracked section. The model relies on the cyclic bridging law, the so-called stress-crack-width relation under cyclic tensile load as the fundamental constitutive relationship in tension. The structural size effect on fatigue in bending of concrete beams is studied by the present model. Eight series of beams, with heights from 50 to 800 mm, are analvzed. The model results show that the fatigue performance in bending, normally expressed in terms of the maximum flexural stress versus fatigue life diagram (S-N) is strongly dependent on the structural size, even when the same material parameters are used in the model. Under the same cyclic flexural stress levels, the smaller the beam height, the longer the fatigue life is. Besides this, the deformation characteristics, such as fatigue crack growth history as well as the final fatigue crack length, are also size dependent. Finally, the model predictions are compared with experimental results. Good agreement between model predictions and experiments has been obtained.
Size Effect in Axially Loaded Reinforced Concrete Columns Confined by BFRP Sheets

Liang Han

2009-01-01

Journal of Functional Biomaterials

Abstract:In order to study the size effect,the axial compression experiment of three kinds dimension specimens were conducted.27 specimens were made and tested and 12 of them were confined by BFRP sheets and the others are no-confined ones.The diameters of columns are 150,200 and 250mm and they were divided in 3 groups by different geometrical dimensions.The diameters of longitudinal reinforcement and stirrups and the number of BFRP layers were designed according to the same ratio of 3∶4∶5.The experimental results showed that the nominal stress of the specimens descended as the dimension of specimens increase and this showed that the size effect exist in the strength of the specimens.And the size effect of the specimens has good agreement with the Bazant size-effect law.

Analysis and Application of Bazant's Size Effect Laws

New Statistical Quantification Method for the Size Effect Behavior of Rock Mass Using Compressive Strength As an Example

Numerical analysis of concrete strength size effect on meso-level

Effect of Aggregate on Cracking Behaviours of Concrete in Mesoscopic Modeling

Research of Loading Effects of Blast in Air

Size Effect for Normal Strength Concrete in Uniaxial Tension

A Practical Discrete Sizing Optimization Methodology for the Design of High-Rise Concrete Buildings

Experimental Description of Size Effect for Brittle Materials Using Specimens with Fixed Crack Length

Stress-Strain Behavior of Cementitious Materials with Different Sizes

Numerical and theoretical investigation on the size effect of concrete compressive strength considering the maximum aggregate size

Size Effects on Mechanical Properties of Micro/Nano Structures

A Mesoscopic Approach for the Size Effect on Fracture Energy of Concrete

Fractal size effect model on fracture energy of concrete

Analytical and Numerical Study of the Size Effect on the Failure Response of Hierarchical Structures

Essential Difference and Design Application of Boundary Effect Model and Size Effect Model

Structural size effect in the mode I and mixed mode I/II fracture of strain-hardening cementitious composites (SHCC)

Effects of Reinforcement Bar on Shrinkage Stress of Concrete

Experimental Study on the Size Effect on the Equation of State of Concretes under Shock Loading

Size Effects of Concrete Gravity Dams Based on XFEM Analyses

Size Effect On Fatigue In Bending Of Concrete

Size Effect in Axially Loaded Reinforced Concrete Columns Confined by BFRP Sheets