Abstract:The application of three-way data sets (combined multisite data sets) for source apportionment has become common, but its influence on the performance of receptor modeling techniques has not yet been explored systematically To study the influence of site-to-site correlations of source contributions and the spatial variability of source profiles on two- and three-way positive matrix factorization (PMF), simulated three-way data sets were constructed and modeled by different applications of PMF (PMF2 for each site individually, PMF2 for data sets combining all sites together, and PMF3 for all sites). In addition, the performance of PMF was evaluated under conditions of collinearity and different source categories at two sites. The results indicated that if the sites were contributed by sources with identical profiles, the site-to-site correlations of source contributions would not influence the PMF2, and the three-way blocks could be used by PMF2. However, the PMF2 using three-way data sets was sensitive to the spatial variability of source profiles. For the three-way model, PMF3 could perform well only when all of the sources exhibited strong site-to-site associations among all sites, and at the same time, the spatial variability of source profiles were sufficiently small. It might due to the algorithm that, for each source, PMF3 produces the same source profile and the same temporal variation in daily contributions among all sites.Implications: The application of multisite data sets for source apportionment has become common However, limited work investigated the accuracy of two- and three-way PMFs when using multisite data sets. If the application of PMFs using multisite data sets were not appropriate, the results would be unreasonable. The unreasonable results would supply confused information for PM control strategies. In this work, simulated multisite data sets were modeled by different applications of PMFs. The effort to assess and compare the performance of two- and three-way PMFs using multisite data sets is very limited. The findings could provide information for multisite source apportionment.

Evaluating the performance of PMF model for Atmospheric PM source apportionment in multi-site

Quantification of Source Impact to Pm Using Three-Dimensional Weighted Factor Model Analysis on Multi-Site Data

Improving Apportionment of PM2.5 Using Multisite PMF by Constraining G-values with a Prioriinformation.

Combination of Multiple Isotopes and PMF Model Provide Insights Into the Method Optimization of PM2.5 Source Apportionment During Haze Episodes

Source apportionment of fine particulate matter at a megacity in China, using an improved regularization supervised PMF model

Spatial source apportionment of airborne coarse particulate matter using PMF-Bayesian receptor model

Combining Positive Matrix Factorization and Radiocarbon Measurements for Source Apportionment of PM 2.5 from a National Background Site in North China.

A Comparison of Multiple Combined Models for Source Apportionment, Including the PCA/MLR-CMB, Unmix-CMB and PMF-CMB Models

Insight into PM<sub>2.5</sub> Sources by Applying Positive Matrix Factorization (PMF) at an Urban and Rural Site of Beijing

Insight into PM 2.5 Sources by Applying Positive Matrix Factorization (PMF) at an Urban and Rural Site of Beijing

Evaluating the Influence of Constant Source Profile Presumption on PMF Analysis of PM2.5 by Comparing Long- and Short-Term Hourly Observation-Based Modeling

Insight into PM<sub>2.5</sub> sources by applying positive matrix factorization (PMF) at urban and rural sites of Beijing

Source Apportionment of PM2.5 Using Hourly Measurements of Elemental Tracers and Major Constituents in an Urban Environment: Investigation of Time‐Resolution Influence

Seasonal Variations and Source Apportionment of Ambient PM10 and PM2.5 at Urban Area of Hefei, China

The Accuracy of Two- and Three-Way Positive Matrix Factorization Models: Applying Simulated Multisite Data Sets

Using a New WALSPMF Model to Quantify the Source Contributions to PM2.5 at a Harbour Site in China

Towards a better understanding of fine PM sources: Online and offline datasets combination in a single PMF

Approaches for Identifying PM2.5 Source Types and Source Areas at a Remote Background Site of South China in Spring

PM2.5 Source Apportionment Identified with Total and Soluble Elements in Positive Matrix Factorization.

Combined Source Apportionment, Using Positive Matrix Factorization–chemical Mass Balance and Principal Component Analysis/multiple Linear Regression–chemical Mass Balance Models

High Time Resolution Source Apportionment of PM2.5 in Beijing with Multiple Models