A System Dynamics Study of Optimal Decision-Making for Water Resource Distribution in the Weihe River Basin
WANG Wu-ke,LI Tong-sheng,XU Dong-ping,ZHANG Jie
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1007-7588.2008.07.004
2008-01-01
Abstract:A water resource regulation system is a large open system with a complex high-order, multi-variable, multi-loop and nonlinear feedback structure. The behavior of the system is typically contrary to the internal characteristics of the system. Applying system dynamics methods to establish models of water resource allocation can simulate the system's nonlinear structure and dynamic character more accurately than traditional mathematical models. We use the Guanzhong area in Weihe River Basin as a case study. First, the factors affecting water resources distribution in Weihe River Basin were analyzed. Then, we built a model system using a system dynamics (SD) approach. Based on the system structure and different water resource distribution coefficients, five different allocation programs (labeled ‘planning’,‘economic prior development’, ‘ecological protection’, ‘water demand’, and ‘volume of water shortage’) were developed and simulated with Vensim PLE to study the operation of different programs through 2020. In order to assess and compare the different simulation results, we used gray system comprehensive assessment methods and chose six indexes incorporating ecological, economic and social aspects. This method of assessment was used to select the optimal distribution scheme, which is the ‘volume of water shortage’ program (R_E=0.589). It takes both economic development and environmental protection into account, with obvious economic and ecological benefits (l_E (1)=0.718, l_E (4)=0.846). It is not the best program according to either economic development or ecological protection individually (l_B(1)=1.000, l_C(3)=1.000), but it is the best choice for balancing the two in a sustainable development approach, and can improve the benefits of water utilization in the Weihe River Basin (l_E(3)=1.000).In order to effectively resolve water shortage problems and coordinate water systems and socio-economic systems in the Weihe River Basin, there should be increased water diversion from other zones, and the current distribution system needs to be optimized and adjusted. Taking into consideration all factors affecting water supply and demand, the ‘volume of water shortage’ plan for the Guanzhong area urgently needs to be established, as it would improve marginal efficiency of water resources in all subsystems and maximize the total utilization efficiency of water resources. Only by doing so can the scarce water resources in the Guanzhong area be fully utilized.The challenges of application of SD to a water resources distribution system were analyzed, with two particularly apparent problems. First, there are contradictions between the evolutionary characteristics of the system structure and the invariant features of the SD model. Another problem is that accuracy of the mathematical relationships among the variables will decline with increasingly long time periods. The solutions to these problems need further research.