Comparison and Selection of the Remedial Schemes for Ammonia Nitrogen-Contaminated Groundwater in Landfill Sites

Jing Zhang,Liu Pi,Jiaxin Cui,Xuhui Mao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.16803/j.cnki.issn.1004-6216.2017.03.023

2017-01-01

Abstract:Due to the insufficient countermeasures against leakage, the substandard-discharged leachates from the early simply-constructed landfills caused elevated ammonia nitrogen concentration in the surrounding groundwater. In this study, with regard to the ammonia nitrogen contaminated groundwater in a landfill site located in the Central China, two schemes of pumping and treatment plus ex-situ bioremediation and air sparging plus in-situ bioremediation were proposed. AHP-TOPSIS (analytical hierarchy process-technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution) methodology was used for a comprehensive screening of the remedial schemes on the basis of establishment of a suitable evaluation indicator system. The analytic result indicated that air sparging in combination with in-situ bioremediation was more suitable. Theoretically, TOPSIS lacked the procedures of ascertaining the evaluating index weights, resulting in the restriction in hierarchical multivariate analysis, while AHP was an effective tool for determination of the multi-level and multi-factor weights. Therefore, AHP was firstly used for ascertaining the index weights and then TOPSIS was adopted to rank the candidate remediation schemes so as to mutually make up their own defects. As a result, AHP-TOPSIS could be used as an effective tool for the environmentalists to select the best site remediation plans.