Abstract:R. S. Liu, L. Lemieux, A. Hammers, G. S. Bell, S. M. Sisodiya, S. D. Shorvon, J. W. Sander, J. S. Duncan Institute of Neurology, London, London, United Kingdom Synopsis We investigated the pattern of generalized and focal neocortical atrophy that develops in patients with epilepsy. Patients and controls were scanned 3.5 years apart. Image subtraction was used to identify neocortical change that was quantified by automatic segmentation and a regional brain atlas. New focal or generalized neocortical volume losses were identified in 54% of patients with chronic epilepsy, 39% of newly diagnosed patients and 24% of controls. The increased risk of cerebral atrophy in epilepsy was not related to a history of documented seizures. Cerebral atrophy may therefore be widespread and remote from the epileptic focus. Introduction Cross-sectional quantitative volumetric MRI studies of epilepsy have inferred that the hippocampus, cerebellum, temporal lobe, extratemporal cortical region and cerebral hemisphere are susceptible to volume loss [1-2]. Whether a correlation between seizure frequency and extrahippocampal volume deficit exists is unclear. Longitudinal studies with serial MRI scans allow the quantification of morphological change over time, using an individual’s baseline scan as a reference point. Quantitative MRI studies investigating brain volume changes in epilepsy have generally used regionbased methods. Such methods, however, restrict analyses to areas of a priori interest. We propose a voxel-based analysis method using automatic coregistration, subtraction and segmentation of serial MRI scans and quantification of focal changes of grey matter (GM) and white matter (WM) using a digital atlas. Methods 153 patients with chronic active epilepsy, 90 patients with newly diagnosed seizures and 90 age-and sex-matched control subjects were prospectively recruited from a local population of 207,553. Subjects were scanned on a 1.5-T GE Signa Horizon Echospeed MR scanner (GE Medical Systems, Milwaukee, WI). Three experienced epileptologists classified patients at the time of recruitment according to epilepsy syndrome based on seizure semiology and EEG findings. Of the original cohort, 122 patients with chronic active epilepsy, 68 patients with newly diagnosed seizures and 90 controls were subjected to the follow-up assessment: scanning performed on the same MRI scanner using identical MRI acquisition sequences to the baseline imaging protocol (see below) and clinical data collection. Volumetric measurements were derived from a T1-weighted volumetric inversion recovery prepared spoiled gradient echo (IR-SPGR) coronal sequence, giving 0.93x0.93x1.5mm voxels. Prior to volumetry, baseline and repeat T1-weighted volume datasets were corrected for signal inhomogeneity [3]. The automatic segmentation software program, Exbrain was used to extract the brain in the non-uniformity corrected baseline scan [4-5]. The repeat scan was coregistered and intensity matched to the segmented baseline scan using MRreg [6-7]. The coregistered repeat scan was subsequently resampled using sinc interpolation. Exbrain was used to segment the coregistered image pairs giving GM and WM probability maps [5]. Difference images of the whole brain were generated by subtracting the baseline from the coregistered and intensity-matched repeat scan, spatially normalisation and filtering with a structured noise map to remove changes due to physical artifacts. The structured noise map was derived from the difference images of 40 healthy adults scanned 7 months apart. Two observers rated the resulting filtered difference images, blinded to all clinical information, for change as either: mild, moderate or marked. Quantitative analysis was restricted to areas of signal change highlighted by visual assessment, using a probabilistic anatomical atlas obtained by the spatial normalisation of 20 atlases of normal subjects comprising 49 manually delineated volumes of interest, grouped into 8 regions for our purpose: right and left temporal, frontal, occipital and parietal lobes [8]. The template was spatially transformed into each individual’s MRI space. Application of the atlas to the segmented images resulted in baseline and repeat GM and WM volumes within the regions of interest. Results Individual analysis. The following figures exclude cases obscured by imaging artifacts. New focal or generalized neocortical volume losses were identified in 54% of patients with chronic epilepsy, 39% of newly diagnosed patients and 24% of controls. In the newly diagnosed group, 11% of patients showed a focal neocortical volume loss, 27% showed a generalized volume loss and 2% showed a generalized volume gain. In the chronic group, focal neocortical volume loss was identified in 14% of patients and 41% showed a generalized volume loss, and 2% showed a generalized gain in volume. Loss in TBV associated with mild generalized visual changes was [0.2 3.3%] and [1.4 4.3%] for moderate visual change. Temporal lobe volume losses in temporal lobe GM were [3.6 27.3%] and [5.3 26.9%] for WM. Frontal GM losses were [0.3 7.4%], and WMV losses [1.1 18.8%]. Four percent of patients with chronic TLE without hippocampal sclerosis (HS) and 17% with chronic TLE and HS developed extrahippocampal atrophy. None of the patients with newly diagnosed TLE and 2% of control subjects developed temporal lobe atrophy. Group analysis. Patients with chronic epilepsy were significantly more likely to develop neocortical atrophy than control subjects. The pattern of change was significantly associated with baseline age and AED exposure during the follow-up period. The increased risk of cerebral atrophy in epilepsy was not related to a history of documented seizures. Risk factors for neocortical atrophy were age and multiple antiepileptic drug exposure. Discussion and Conclusions We have proposed a novel approach to the detection and quantification of subtle global and focal volume changes in serial MRI and applied it to a population-based study of the structural consequences of epilepsy. The approach is based on image registration, segmentation, visualisation of difference images and quantification of volume changes by the application of a VOI atlas. The proportions of subjects with neocortical volume loss were far greater in our current study identified than in our previous study on whole-brain and hippocampal volumetry [9-10], reflecting the new method’s superior sensitivity. Our findings suggest that focal and generalized neocortical atrophy commonly develops in chronic epilepsy; Changes seen in a quarter of our controls were likely to reflect physiological changes. Our results show that ongoing cerebral atrophy may be widespread and remote from the putative epileptic focus, possibly reflecting extensive networks and interconnections between cortical regions. References [1] Miller SP et al. Neurology. 2000; 54:1465-1470 [2] Moran NF et al. Brain. 2001; 124:167-175 [3] Sled JG et al. IEEE Trans Med Imaging. 1998; 17:87-97 [4] Lemieux L et al. Magn. Reson. Med. 1999 ; 42(1): 127-135. [5] Lemieux L et al. Magn. Reson. Med. In press. [6] Lemieux L et al. Med Im Anal 1998; 2:227-242. [7] Lemieux L, Barker GJ. Med. Phys. 1998; 25(6):1049-1054. [8] Hammers et al., Hum Brain Mapp. 2002; 15:165-174. [9] Liu RSN et al. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2002; 73: 219. [10] Liu RSN et al. ISMRM 2003, submitted.

Abstract:A common dual pathology observed on presurgical magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of epileptic patients is extrahippocampal lesions combined with mesial temporal sclerosis. The hippocampus was highly vulnerable to many types of insults. However, it is difficult to detect subtle hippocampal atrophy in some patients. The most reliable method to confirm epileptogenicity is chronic intracranial electroencephalography (EEG) monitoring. In this study, we recorded intracranial EEG signals in 11 patients with dual pathology. METHODS Patient enrollment We evaluated 11 patients with a confirmed diagnosis of dual pathology in Yuquan Hospital, China between 2007 and 2010. The patients were satisfied with the following criteria: (1) MRI showed structural lesions in the extrahippocampal lobe; (2) a postoperative follow-up period lasting at least 24 months. For all 11 patients, both seizure frequency and impact on quality of life were judged as severe enough to justify presurgical evaluation using implanted electrodes. Detailed histories of prenatal, neonatal, and early childhood events were systematically reviewed through direct interviews with the patients. Patients were initially evaluated with noninvasive methods, including scalp EEG monitoring to capture spontaneous seizures and MRI. MRI was performed using a 1.5 T scanner and included axial images parallel to the long axis of the hippocampus. Ipsilateral and contralateral hippocampal images were visually compared to confirm mesial temporal sclerosis (MTS). EEG recording and analysis Noninvasive data (scalp EEG and MRI) identified the mesial temporal region and a neocortical lesion site as the most likely ictal onset zones. Thus, all 11 patients were examined by implanted intracranial electrodes. To investigate the mesial temporal region, we used a stereo-eletroencephalography procedure. Depth electrodes were orthogonally directed through the middle temporal gyrus with the deepest contacts in the amygdala and anterior hippocampus. The number of neocortical electrodes implanted varied depending on the target region. Electrode positions were confirmed by post-implantation neuroimaging. Intracranial EEG was recorded at a sampling rate of 256 Hz to capture at least two spontaneous seizures. The seizures were classified by the site of origin of ictal discharges as follows: (1) discharge originating from neocortex and (2) discharge originating independently from hippocampus or amygdala. Subclinical seizures were defined as rhythmic discharges for 10 seconds or longer without subjective symptom or objective change. RESULTS Table 1 showed the clinical data of the 11 cases. Direct interviews with the parents were done in all patients. They could recall the clear histories. Severe head trauma was observed in three patients, one patient had the symptoms at the age of 5 years with fever and conscience impairment and was diagnosed as tuberculous meningitis, and one patient had a febrile convulsion at the age of 2 years. Six patients were considered normal before the initial seizure. MRI detected abnormalities in all patients; one patient revealed atrophy involving the entire cerebral hemisphere and the lesions were localized distributed at frontal or occipital area in six patients. Four patients had localized lesion on the lateral temporal cortex. All of these patients showed some degree of signal change on T2-weighted images, mostly hyperintensity. The mean age at seizure onset was 6.7 years (range 2-13) and at surgery was 17.9 years (range 9-37). For seizure symptoms, nine patients reported auras, seven evolved to complex partial seizures with automatisms, and two patients evolved to ipsilateral arm tonic or clonic. For patient 4, his seizure manifested as hypermotor seizure initially, then became generalized tonic-clonic seizure. In three patients, only the neocortical lesion was resected and the mesial temporal structures were spared. In eight patients, the neocortical lesion and mesial temporal structure were resected simultaneously; the extent of the neocortical lesion resection was determined based on the location and intracranial EEG findings. The mesial temporal structure resection included amygdala and approximately 3.5 cm anterior part of the hippocampus and parahippocampal gyrus. Histological examination revealed ulegyria accompanied by cortical dysplasia in three patients, focal cortical dysplasia in other four patients, and dysembryoplastic neuroepithelial tumor in four patients. Hippocampal neuron loss was seen in eight patients. The mean postoperative follow-up was 28.8 months (range 24-37). Ten patients were led to seizure freedom and Engle' II was found in one patient.Table 1: Preoperative clinical dataIntracranial EEG monitoring continued for a mean of 5.7 days; a total of 68 complex partial seizures and 16 secondarily generalized seizures were captured. Twenty subclinical seizures were also recorded. In 11 patients, many clinical seizures originating from the neocortical lesion were recorded; these clinical seizures constituted more than half of all seizures recorded. Apart from seizures originating from neocortex, 33 complex partial seizures (CPS) or 20 subclinical seizures (SCS) were also recorded independently from mesial temporal structures in these patients. Ictal discharges only originating from neocortical lesion surroundings were recorded in three patients. DISCUSSION The success of epilepsy surgery is judged by cessation of seizure activity, which depends on the removal of tissue that is responsible for epileptogenesis. In the present study, we used intracranially recorded EEG in epilepsy patients suffering from dual pathology to determine the epileptogenic region. Our cases showed that more than half of clinical seizures arise from the region in the vicinity of the extrahippocampal lesion; this result supported the view that the seizure onset zone often existed in the cortex surrounding the structural damage. This is based on the assumption that epileptogenicity tends to be formed in the vicinity of the lesion in epileptic patient with localized structural lesions.1 Several mechanisms have been suggested for the susceptibility of epileptogenicity formation in the vicinity of structural lesions, including local neuronal injury, glial proliferation, vascular changes, and neurotransmitter changes. In addition, the presence of intrinsic epileptogenicity in dysplastic cortex has been suggested. Previous studies addressed the problem of the most efficacious surgical approach for patients with dual pathology. Cascino et al2 reported on three patients who exhibited seizure control only after a second operation in which the atrophic hippocampal was removed. Since the resected regions of the reoperations contained the hippocampus, epileptogenicity of the hippocampus attracted attention. To confirm epileptogenicity of the hippocampus, a direct method is to record ictal discharges in intracranial EEG. In our patients, a total of 33 clinical seizures and 20 subclinical seizures originated independently from hippocampus; all seizures only originated from hippocampus in three patients. These findings supported the presence of epileptogenicity in the mesial temporal structures independent of the epileptogenicity in the vicinity of the neocortical lesion. Reports from Mathern et al3 also found 11 patients had ictal discharges from the mesial structure among 16 patients with structural lesions. The pathogenesis of this dual pathology is still unclear. One possibility is that extrahippocampal lesions produce seizures that, if uncontrolled, gradually induce MTS and temporal lobe epilepsy. Indeed, animal studies showed that repetitive stimulation of inputs to the hippocampus produces a pathology resembling temporal sclerosis.4 However, several studies found that the degree of hippocampal atrophy was not related to the duration or severity of seizures. This suggested that a common pathogenic mechanism may cause concomitant hippocampal sclerosis and extrahippocampal lesions in these patients and repetitive neocortical seizures may have only a minor role in the progression of hippocampal damage. In some cases, seizures were initially tonic-clonic, but slowly transformed to complex partial seizures involving the mesial temporal area. This indicated that sclerosis of the mesial temporal region may require several years after the initial brain insult. Li et al5 compared the results between lesionectomy, resection of the atrophic hippocampus, and the combination of both procedures in patients with diverse pathologies. Although the sample was small, this study suggested that the combination of the two procedures offered the best seizure control. The same authors expanded the number of patients in a second report and confirmed their first results; they concluded that resection of both lesions should be considered whenever possible. Identification of hippocampal sclerosis in patients with neocortical epilepsies is important for optimal surgical treatment and for prognosis of postoperative seizure outcome. Because of the small sample in this study, further studies are required to investigate the intracranial EEG in epileptic patients with dual pathology.

Reversible cranial lesions after epilepsy--report of 2 cases and literature review

Reversible Splenial Lesion Syndrome in Children with Benign Convulsions Associated with Mild Gastroenteritis: A Retrospective Study of Five Cases

Lesional Intractable Epileptic Spasms in Children: Electroclinical Localization and Postoperative Outcomes

Reversible Splenial Lesion Syndrome with Some Novel Causes and Clinical Manifestations.

MRI in the presurgical evaluation of patients with frontal lobe epilepsy and children with temporal lobe epilepsy: pathologic correlation and prognostic importance

Impact of MRI Changes on Seizure Outcome in Patients of Temporal Lobe Epilepsy

The pathology of magnetic-resonance-imaging-negative epilepsy

Brain MRI in status epilepticus: Relevance of findings

A Study on Localization of Epileptogenic Zones in Refractory Epilepsy Patients with Non-Lesional MRI and CT Findings

Clinical appearances and MR imaging diagnosis of reversible splenial lesion syndrom (RESLES)

Seizure Duration and Spread Dynamics in MRI-Defined Subtypes of Temporal Lobe Epilepsy

MRI Findings of Posterior Reversible Encephalopathy Syndrome

Serial Quantitative Atlas-based MRI Volumetry to Assess Progressive Neocortical Damage in Epilepsy

Epileptic foci and networks in children with epilepsy after acute encephalopathy with biphasic seizures and late reduced diffusion

Imaging of status epilepticus: Making the invisible visible. A prospective study on 206 patients

Intracranial Electroencephalography Study in Epileptic Patients with Dual Pathology.

Long-term seizure outcome in patients undergoing resection of lesions detected by magnetic resonance imaging

Microstructural features of the cerebral cortex: Implications for predicting epilepsy relapse after drug withdrawal

Non-convulsive Seizures Mimicking Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease with Rapid Resolution and Recurrence of MRI Abnormalities

Clinical and MRI observations of symptomatic epilepsy-related primary brain tumors

A longitudinal quantitative MRI study of community-based patients with chronic epilepsy and newly diagnosed seizures: methodology and preliminary findings.