Abstract:We examine the effectiveness of institutional investors in constraining aggressive earnings management induced by strong contractual incentives. To this end we focus on the consequences of earnings-related promises (covenants) negotiated between corporate controlling shareholders and minority shareholders during China's split-share structure reform, wherein failure to achieve profit benchmarks had the potential to transfer significant wealth from controlling to minority shareholders. Our initial analysis provides evidence that profit-promised firm-years are, on average, associated with income-increasing earnings management, and that this association is stronger for: (i) firm-years in which the profit-promise was satisfied, and (ii) firm-years in which proxies for the level of unmanaged earnings suggest that earnings management was needed to satisfy the promise. However, such benchmark-beating behavior is weaker for firms with higher levels of institutional ownership. Further analysis documents that the exit threat of institutional shareholders can discipline earnings management associated with profit promises. We also show that the effect of institutional shareholders in reducing earnings management associated with profit promises is greater for domestic mutual funds and for privately controlled firms. Interestingly, our evidence suggests that institutional investors only play an effective monitoring role over earnings management when their incentives are strongly aligned with those of other minority owners. In other cases, our evidence suggests that these investors may exacerbate the level of earnings management.

Controlling Shareholder's Private Benefits under the Condition of Restricted Shares' Selling——from the Point of Intertemporal Investment

Corporate Ownership Structure and Cash Holding in Family Controlled Firms: Evidence from the NTS Reform in China

Disproportional Ownership Structure and Stock Market Liquidity in China

Do Private Equity Investors Conspire with Ultimate Owners in the IPO Process?

Disproportionate Ownership Structure and IPO Long-Run Performance of Non-Soes in China

Expropriation of Minority Shareholders in Politically Connected Firms

The Control Right of Ultimate Controlling Shareholder and Overinvestment of Free Cash Flow

A Review of Controlling Shareholder's Expropriation and Corporate Governance in Ownership Concentrated Market

Separation of Control and Cash-Flow Rights of State Owned Listed Enterprises: Channels of Expropriation after the Discriminated Share Reform in China

On the Effectiveness of Restricted Share Purchase by a Limited Company

Ultimate Ownership, Institutions And Listed Companies' Debt Financing Based On The Perspective Of Controlling Shareholders

Controlling Shareholder, Expropriations and Firm's Leverage Decision: Evidence from Chinese Non-Tradable Share Reform

Multi-Factor Collaborative Governance of Controlling Shareholder Expropriation Behavior in Emerging Economies: A Perspective of Double Principal-Agent Conflicts

Does Expropriation of Large Shareholders Change Corporate Investment Behaviors? Evidence from Chinese Listed Companies

Dynamic Analysis of Large Shareholders' Private Benefits from Control Power

Debt of Bank, Institutional Environment and the Agent Cost of Controlling Shareholder

Split-Share Structure Reform and Interests of Private Ultimate Controllers——Evidences from China's Public-Trade Firms

Ultimate ownership, institutions and listed companies' debt financing

Expropriation and Incentives for Team Production

Controlling Shareholders’ Incentive and Corporate Tax Avoidance: A Natural Experiment in China

Institutional Investors and Earnings Management Associated with Controlling Shareholders' Promises: Evidence from the Split Share Structure Reform in China