Abstract:A credit default is a negative event for individual borrowers, and lenders and at scale, can impact the broader economy. To protect against losses, lenders seek to maintain robust lending practices through optimising credit risk assessment. The credit risk modelling literature is extensive, yet many studies suffer from flaws stifling adoption by industry. Nonlinear algorithms are often incorporated for comparison purposes, nevertheless, a comprehensive explanation of variables and their treatment is not always provided. Furthermore, the publicly available data sets do not necessarily contain important financial variables and their limited sample size raises questions regarding their statistical power. Commonly the focus is on statistical performance as opposed to optimizing the commercial outcome motivating the use of credit scorecards. However, financial institutions are more interested in optimizing profits by reducing the cost arising from false assessments of credit applicants. In this research, we simulated important financial variables recommended by industry to append to German Credit Dataset to compare optimised credit risk assessment models. The performance of Logistic Regression is compared with Random Forest, Gradient Boosting Machine and Artificial Neural Network. A new financial performance metric is developed to estimate the costs arising from both false positives and false negatives, and compared with statistical criteria; Area under the Receiver Operating Curve, Accuracy and Somers' Delta. Four typical asset classes; Credit Cards, Small and Large Loans, and Mortgages are simulated to determine which algorithm outperforms in estimating costs. The results demonstrate that Artificial Neural Network outperforms other methods, and our approach ranks models differently from the purely statistical measures. The proposed cost metric would provide a significant financial benefit to organisations.

Determination of Weights for an Optimal Credit Rating Model Based on Default and Nondefault Distance Maximization

Optimal Capital Allocation Based on Weighted-Mean-Variance Principle

Evaluating the Default Risk of Bond Portfolios with Extreme Value Theory

An enterprise default discriminant model based on optimal misjudgment loss ratio

Model of credit rating of micro enterprise based on fuzzy integration

A Study on Credit Risk Measurement of Chinese Commercial Banks

Combination Weighting Approach Based on Deviation Function and Joint-Entropy

A Study on Logistic Model Taking into Account Distance to Default

Optimal Credit Scorecard Model Selection Using Costs Arising from Both False Positives and False Negatives

Entropy method of constructing a combined model for improving loan default prediction: A case study in China

A Multicriteria Approach for Modeling Small Enterprise Credit Rating: Evidence from China

Credit Evaluation Model of Road Transportation Enterprises Based on the Combination Weighting Method

A novel two-stage hybrid default prediction model with k-means clustering and support vector domain description

A two-stage credit scoring model based on random forest: Evidence from Chinese small firms

A New Model to Improve Credit Rating under Incidence Relation

Using a genetic backpropagation neural network model for credit risk assessment in the micro, small and medium-sized enterprises

Corporate financial distress diagnosis model and application in credit rating for listing firms in China

Prediction of Micro- and Small-Sized Enterprise Default Risk Based on a Logistic Model: Evidence from a Bank of China

Credit Debt Default Risk Assessment Based on the XGBoost Algorithm: An Empirical Study from China

Credit scoring model based on a novel group feature selection method: The case of Chinese small-sized manufacturing enterprises

Personal Loan Default Prediction Based on LightGBM Model and Zhima Credit