Abstract:Background Modern clinical care in intensive care units is full of rich data, and machine learning has great potential to support clinical decision-making. The development of intelligent machine learning–based clinical decision support systems is facing great opportunities and challenges. Clinical decision support systems may directly help clinicians accurately diagnose, predict outcomes, identify risk events, or decide treatments at the point of care. Objective We aimed to review the research and application of machine learning–enabled clinical decision support studies in intensive care units to help clinicians, researchers, developers, and policy makers better understand the advantages and limitations of machine learning–supported diagnosis, outcome prediction, risk event identification, and intensive care unit point-of-care recommendations. Methods We searched papers published in the PubMed database between January 1980 and October 2020. We defined selection criteria to identify papers that focused on machine learning–enabled clinical decision support studies in intensive care units and reviewed the following aspects: research topics, study cohorts, machine learning models, analysis variables, and evaluation metrics. Results A total of 643 papers were collected, and using our selection criteria, 97 studies were found. Studies were categorized into 4 topics—monitoring, detection, and diagnosis (13/97, 13.4%), early identification of clinical events (32/97, 33.0%), outcome prediction and prognosis assessment (46/97, 47.6%), and treatment decision (6/97, 6.2%). Of the 97 papers, 82 (84.5%) studies used data from adult patients, 9 (9.3%) studies used data from pediatric patients, and 6 (6.2%) studies used data from neonates. We found that 65 (67.0%) studies used data from a single center, and 32 (33.0%) studies used a multicenter data set; 88 (90.7%) studies used supervised learning, 3 (3.1%) studies used unsupervised learning, and 6 (6.2%) studies used reinforcement learning. Clinical variable categories, starting with the most frequently used, were demographic (n=74), laboratory values (n=59), vital signs (n=55), scores (n=48), ventilation parameters (n=43), comorbidities (n=27), medications (n=18), outcome (n=14), fluid balance (n=13), nonmedicine therapy (n=10), symptoms (n=7), and medical history (n=4). The most frequently adopted evaluation metrics for clinical data modeling studies included area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (n=61), sensitivity (n=51), specificity (n=41), accuracy (n=29), and positive predictive value (n=23). Conclusions Early identification of clinical and outcome prediction and prognosis assessment contributed to approximately 80% of studies included in this review. Using new algorithms to solve intensive care unit clinical problems by developing reinforcement learning, active learning, and time-series analysis methods for clinical decision support will be greater development prospects in the future.

Machine Learning-Based Patient Classification System for Adult Patients in Intensive Care Units: A Cross-Sectional Study.

Machine Learning and Initial Nursing Assessment-Based Triage System for Emergency Department

Patient stratification based on the risk of severe illness in emergency departments through collaborative machine learning models

A machine learning-based risk stratification tool for in-hospital mortality of intensive care unit patients with heart failure

Early Warning Models Using Machine Learning to Predict Sepsis-Associated Chronic Critical Illness: A Study Based on the Medical Information Mart for Intensive Care Database

Machine learning-derived blood culture classification with both predictive and prognostic values in the intensive care unit: A retrospective cohort study

Using machine learning tools to predict outcomes for emergency department intensive care unit patients

Predicting Intensive Care Unit admission among patients presenting to the emergency department using machine learning and natural language processing

A Machine Learning Based Discharge Prediction of Cardiovascular Diseases Patients in Intensive Care Units

ICU Patients’ Pattern Recognition and Correlation Identification of Vital Parameters Using Optimized Machine Learning Models

An Optimized Machine Learning Model Accurately Predicts In-Hospital Outcomes at Admission to a Cardiac Unit

Machine Learning Models for Predicting Critical Illness Risk in Hospitalized Patients with COVID-19 Pneumonia.

Development and validation of a machine learning algorithm–based risk prediction model of pressure injury in the intensive care unit

Predicting the Mortality of ICU Patients by Topic Model with Machine-Learning Techniques

State of the Art of Machine Learning–Enabled Clinical Decision Support in Intensive Care Units: Literature Review

[Predicting Prolonged Length of Intensive Care Unit Stay Via Machine Learning].

Criticality and Clinical Department Prediction of ED Patients Using Machine Learning Based on Heterogeneous Medical Data.

A predictive model for the classification of emergency intensive care unit patients with systemic inflammatory response syndrome based on a similarity network fusion algorithm

Classification of COVID-19 in intensive care patients: towards rational and effective triage

Development and Validation of Machine Learning-Based Models for Prediction of Intensive Care Unit Admission and In-Hospital Mortality in Patients with Acute Exacerbations of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease

Prediction of intensive care unit admission (>24h) after surgery in elective noncardiac surgical patients using machine learning algorithms