Abstract:Program debugging is a time-consuming task, and researchers have proposed different kinds of automatic fault localization techniques to mitigate the burden of manual debugging. Among these techniques, two popular families are spectrum-based fault localization (SBFL) and statistical debugging (SD), both localizing faults by collecting statistical information at runtime. Though the ideas are similar, the two families have been developed independently and their combinations have not been systematically explored. In this paper we perform a systematical empirical study on the combination of SBFL and SD. We first build a unified model of the two techniques, and systematically explore four types of variations, different predicates, different risk evaluation formulas, different granularities of data collection, and different methods of combining suspicious scores. Our study leads to several findings. First, most of the effectiveness of the combined approach contributed by a simple type of predicates: branch conditions. Second, the risk evaluation formulas of SBFL significantly outperform that of SD. Third, fine-grained data collection significantly outperforms coarse-grained data collection with a little extra execution overhead. Fourth, a linear combination of SBFL and SD predicates outperforms both individual approaches. According to our empirical study, we propose a new fault localization approach, PredFL (Predicate-based Fault Localization), with the best configuration for each dimension under the unified model. Then, we explore its complementarity to existing techniques by integrating PredFL with a state-of-the-art fault localization framework. The experimental results show that PredFL can further improve the effectiveness of state-of-the-art fault localization techniques. More concretely, integrating PredFL results in an up to 20.8% improvement w.r.t the faults successfully located at Top-1, which reveals that PredFL complements existing techniques.

A Lightweight Fault Localization Approach based on XGBoost

A Dynamic Fault Localization Technique with Noise Reduction for Java Programs

Effective Multi-Fault Localization Based on Fault-Relevant Statistics

Feature-FL: Feature-Based Fault Localization

A fault localization approach based on fault propagation context

Fault Classification Oriented Spectrum Based Fault Localization

An Improvement to Fault Localization Technique Based on Branch-Coverage Spectra.

A Hybrid Approach to Fine-grained Automated Fault Localization

GBSR: Graph-based Suspiciousness Refinement for Improving Fault Localization

Isolating Suspiciousness from Spectrum-Based Fault Localization Techniques

Towards More Accurate Fault Localization: An Approach Based on Feature Selection Using Branching Execution Probability

A Fault Localization Framework to Alleviate the Impact of Execution Similarity

Irbfl: An Information Retrieval Based Fault Localization Approach

Boosting Spectrum-Based Fault Localization via Multi-Correct Programs in Online Programming

ABFL: an Autoencoder Based Practical Approach for Software Fault Localization.

HetFL: Heterogeneous Graph-based Software Fault Localization

Improving Fault Localization through Fault Propagation Analysis

Combining Spectrum-Based Fault Localization and Statistical Debugging - An Empirical Study.

MCFL: Improving Fault Localization by Differentiating Missing Code and Other Faults

Fault localization via behavioral models

A LambdaMart-Based High-Accuracy Approach for Software Automatic Fault Localization