Abstract:The reactivity of think-alouds (TAs) (i.e., their effects on thinking) has remained an inevitable concern whenever their use is considered or evaluated. This paper reports findings from a study that involved 85 Chinese sophomores, who, having received some instruction in diction, and then written a narrative in English as a baseline task, completed a similar main writing task, either silently or while thinking aloud. Between-groups differences were analysed in 20 measures of writing performance. TA was found to significantly impair only two measures, lexical diversity and nondysfluencies. TA may have constrained newly developed, still unstable thoughts that were perceived as peripheral, apart from its effects on fluency. Further analyses revealed differential effects. Those with high working memory capacity (WMC), especially high reading span, were most affected in lexical diversity, while those with low WMC experienced a significant decline in organization. The participants' reflections in a follow-up questionnaire, analyzed inductively, show their diverse feelings about the effects of TA, its processing load emerging as the likely primary reactivity-causing factor. Results suggest that, although the reactivity of TAs is small, participants' between- and within-individual differences should be duly attended to in conducting TAs in second language writing and writing research.

Effects Of Thinking Aloud On Cognitive Effort In Translation

Dictating Translations with Automatic Speech Recognition: Effects on Translators' Performance.

The Influence of Translation Practice on College Students' Concept Relations of Mental Lexicon

Taxing Brings Benefits

A cognitive inquiry into similarities and differences between translation and paraphrase: Evidence from eye movement data.

Cognitive load and cognitive effort

An eye-tracking study of productivity and effort in Chinese-to-English translation and post-editing

Cognitive Load and Translation Accuracy in Technology Assisted Simultaneous Interpreting Enabled by Artificial Intelligence

Think-Aloud-Based Translation Process Research: Some Methodological Considerations

The reactivity of think-alouds in writing research: quantitative and qualitative evidence from writing in English as a foreign language

Cognitive effort in human translation and machine translation post-editing processes

A Comparative Study on the Effort of Human Translation and Post-Editing in Relation to Text Types: An Eye-Tracking and Key-Logging Experiment

The Effect of Using Eye Tracking and Thinking: A loud technique to assist foreign language learners to recognize and understand the meaning of English words in reading texts

Post-editing Machine Translated Subtitles: Examining the Effects of Non-Verbal Input on Student Translators’ Effort

Measuring Translation Difficulty an Empirical Study

The Think-Aloud Protocol——Exploring the Internal Process of Translation

A Study on Cognitive Mechanism of Word Translation in Chinese-English Learners

Eye-Tracking Study of Cognitive Effort in Processing of Lexical Features in Students and Experts

Time Pressure in Translation

Measuring Translation Difficulty: Theoretical and Methodological Considerations

Time pressure in translation Psychological and physiological measures