Abstract:Due to the high complexity of biological data it is difficult to disentangle cellular processes relying only on intuitive interpretation of measurements. A Systems Biology approach that combines quantitative experimental data with dynamic mathematical modeling promises to yield deeper insights into these processes. Nevertheless, with growing complexity and increasing amount of quantitative experimental data, building realistic and reliable mathematical models can become a challenging task: the quality of experimental data has to be assessed objectively, unknown model parameters need to be estimated from the experimental data, and numerical calculations need to be precise and efficient. Here, we discuss, compare and characterize the performance of computational methods throughout the process of quantitative dynamic modeling using two previously established examples, for which quantitative, dose- and time-resolved experimental data are available. In particular, we present an approach that allows to determine the quality of experimental data in an efficient, objective and automated manner. Using this approach data generated by different measurement techniques and even in single replicates can be reliably used for mathematical modeling. For the estimation of unknown model parameters, the performance of different optimization algorithms was compared systematically. Our results show that deterministic derivative-based optimization employing the sensitivity equations in combination with a multi-start strategy based on latin hypercube sampling outperforms the other methods by orders of magnitude in accuracy and speed. Finally, we investigated transformations that yield a more efficient parameterization of the model and therefore lead to a further enhancement in optimization performance. We provide a freely available open source software package that implements the algorithms and examples compared here.

Bayesian Model Selection Methods and Their Application to Biological ODE Systems

Model Selection for Ordinary Differential Equations: A Statistical Testing Approach

Model selection focusing on longtime behavior of differential equations

High-dimensional Bayesian Parameter Estimation: Case Study for a Model of JAK2/STAT5 Signaling.

Data2Dynamics: a Modeling Environment Tailored to Parameter Estimation in Dynamical Systems.

Lessons Learned from Quantitative Dynamical Modeling in Systems Biology

Bayesian model selection for complex dynamic systems

Bayesian Parameter Estimation for Biochemical Reaction Networks Using Region-Based Adaptive Parallel Tempering

Identifying Latent Dynamic Components in Biological Systems

Using Experimental Data and Information Criteria to Guide Model Selection for Reaction–Diffusion Problems in Mathematical Biology

Bayesian model selection in complex linear systems, as illustrated in genetic association studies

Bayesian Inference for Kinetic Models of Biotransformation Using A Generalized Rate Equation

Parameter inference and model selection in deterministic and stochastic dynamical models via approximate Bayesian computation: modeling a wildlife epidemic

A Bayesian Approach for Data-Driven Dynamic Equation Discovery

Scalable Parameter Estimation for Genome-Scale Biochemical Reaction Networks

Gradient Matching Methods for Computational Inference in Mechanistic Models for Systems Biology: A Review and Comparative Analysis

An adaptive scheduling scheme for calculating Bayes factors with thermodynamic integration using Simpson’s rule

Approximate Bayesian computation scheme for parameter inference and model selection in dynamical systems

Bayesian Neural Ordinary Differential Equations

Parameter estimation and model selection for stochastic differential equations for biological growth