Abstract:This paper reviews the role of uncertainty in the identification of mathematical models of water quality and in the application of these models to problems of prediction. More specifically, four problem areas are examined in detail: uncertainty about model structure, uncertainty in the estimated model parameter values, the propagation of prediction errors, and the design of experiments in order to reduce the critical uncertainties associated with a model. The review is rather lengthy, and it has therefore been prepared in effect as two papers. There is a shorter, largely nontechnical version, which gives a quick impression of the current and future issues in the analysis of uncertainty in water quality modeling. Enclosed by this shorter discussion is the main body of the review dealing in turn with (1) identifiability and experimental design, (2) the generation of preliminary model hypotheses under conditions of sparse, grossly uncertain field data, (3) the selection and evaluation of model structure, (4) parameter estimation (model calibration), (5) checks and balances on the identified model, i.e., model “verification” and model discrimination, and (6) prediction error propagation. Much time is spent in discussing the algorithms of system identification, in particular, the methods of recursive estimation, and in relating these algorithms and the subject of identification to the problems of prediction uncertainty and first‐order error analysis. There are two obvious omissions from the review. It is not concerned primarily with either the development and solution of stochastic differential equations or the issue of decision making under uncertainty, although clearly some reference must be made to these topics. In brief, the review concludes (not surprisingly) that much work has been done on the analysis of uncertainty in the development of mathematical models of water quality, and much remains to be done. A lack of model identifiability has been an outstanding difficulty in the interpretation and explanation of past observed system behavior, and there is ample evidence to show that the “larger,” more “comprehensive” models are easily capable of generating highly uncertain predictions of future behavior. For the future of the subject, it is speculated that there is the possibility of progress in the development of novel algorithms for model structure identification, a need for new questions to be posed in the problem of prediction, and a distinct challenge to the conventional views of this review in the new forms of knowledge representation and manipulation now emerging from the field of artificial intelligence.

Cognition in the uncertainty and equifinality of hydrological model: a systematic review

Uncertainty Analysis in Statistical Modeling of Extreme Hydrological Events

Decision-making in Water Management under Uncertainty

Uncertainty in High and Low Flows Due to Model Structure and Parameter Errors

Application of Uncertainty and Sensitivity Analysis in River Basin Management.

Decision Rules for Water Resources Management under Uncertainty

Uncertainty analysis for decision-making in river basin management

Review: Sources of Hydrological Model Uncertainties and Advances in Their Analysis

Water quality modeling: A review of the analysis of uncertainty

Retrospect and prospect of watershed hydrological model

Uncertainty of hydrologic model and general framework of ensemble simulation

Review of the Uncertainty Analysis of Groundwater Numerical Simulation

An Improved Calibration and Uncertainty Analysis Approach Using a Multicriteria Sequential Algorithm for Hydrological Modeling

Impacts of changes in the watershed partitioning level and optimization algorithm on runoff simulation: decomposition of uncertainties

Uncertainty quantification in watershed hydrology: Which method to use?

Uncertainty analysis of groundwater flow conceptual model

Progress of Certainty and Uncertainty Methods of Hydrologic and the Framework of Ensemble Analysis

Uncertainty Quantification in Inverse Models in Hydrology

Parameter estimation and uncertainty analysis in hydrological modeling

What We Talk About When We Talk About Uncertainty. Toward a Unified, Data-Driven Framework for Uncertainty Characterization in Hydrogeology

Uncertainty quantization of meteorological input and model parameters for hydrological modelling using a Bayesian‐based integrated approach