Verb frame distribution and text difficulty: A corpus‐based analysis of verb frames in Chinese textbooks
Meichun Liu,Zhuo Zhang,John Sie Yuen Lee
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/ijal.12511
2023-11-14
International Journal of Applied Linguistics
Abstract:This study aims to explore how verb frames can potentially influence text difficulty and shed new light on text evaluation. Different from previous works focusing mostly on lexical frequencies, this paper explores semantic categories of verbs and their correlation with the difficulty levels (DLs) of textbooks. Based on a corpus of nine sets of primary school Chinese textbooks, verb‐frame diversity and distribution trends by difficulty levels were examined. The results show that the diversity of verb frames has a strong positive correlation with difficulty levels. The distribution trends of the frames largely correspond with the three cognitive tiers proposed in the skill theory for language development: the sensory–motor, representational, and abstract tiers. This study introduces verb frames as a salient semantic factor in text analysis and proposes that verb‐frame‐related features have the potential to be utilized in the evaluation of leveled instructional materials and readability assessment. 摘要 本研究旨在探討動詞語義框架對文本難度的影響, 並為文本評估提供新的視角。在詞彙對文本難度影響方面, 前人主要關注詞彙頻率, 而本文探討了動詞語義類別及其與教材難度水平的相關關係。具體而言, 本研究基於小學語文教科書語料庫, 探究了不同難度水平下的動詞框架多樣性和分佈趨勢。結果顯示, 動詞框架的多樣性與難度水平呈現出強正相關關係; 意即, 教材級別越高, 語義框架的分佈越多樣。動詞語義框架的分佈趨勢在很大程度上與語言發展技能理論中提出的感知‐運動、表徵和抽象三個認知層次相符。本研究將動詞框架作為語義特徵引入文本難度分析, 並提出動詞框架相關特徵在分級教材評估和可讀性評估中具有潛在的應用價值。
education & educational research,linguistics