Abstract:In magnetic fusion, energetic particles (EPs) supplied from neutral beam injection or fusion reaction are crucial for high performance operation of present machines and future reactors [1]. Alfven Eigenmodes (AEs), excited by EPs, play an essential role on EP confinement. An AE is excited in a frequency gap between neighboring MHD continua, where continuum damping is absent so that EP drive can easily excite a mode. AEs excited in toroidicity induced gap (TAE), ellipticity induced gap (EAE) and in higher frequency gaps have been extensively studied and are relatively well-understood. However, there has been much less attention to lower-frequency AEs excited in beta-induced gaps [2][3]. There exist two classes of the beta-induced gaps, which correspond to beta-induced AE (BAE) and beta-induced Alfven-Acoustic Eigenmode (BAAE). The latter is excited in the lowest frequency gap induced by coupling of a slow magnetosonic wave with a shear Alfven wave. Even after theoretical and simulation works in recent three decades, understanding of the low-frequency AEs is not mature. The main reason is that most of theories and simulations have focused on accumulation points or perturbation to damped modes, not seriously considering effects of strong drives. In this work, we have performed gyrokinetic simulations using GTC [4] to study physics of unstable BAE and BAAE in DIII-D #178631. Note that in DIII-D #178631 and in other recent discharges, excited BAAEs have been observed even without neutral beams [5]. Obviously, these BAAEs are not conventional. Therefore, in this work, we call them “Lower-Frequency Modes (LFMs)” instead of “BAAEs”, to be cautious on their physics identification. For the GTC simulations, we have used equilibrium and profiles of DIII-D #178631, provided from EFIT and TRANSP/NUBEAM. Fig. 1 is a primary result of linear GTC simulations of BAE and LFM, with sub-TAE MHD continua calculated from ALCON. The BAE is excited with both relaxed and classical fast ion profiles, having frequency close to the lower continuum in the BAE gap. This is different from a prediction from theories that BAE would be excited near the BAE accumulation point which is local minimum of the upper continuum. GTC finds an excited LFM without fast ions, consistent with experimental observation. Both BAE and LFM have peaks close to qmin, consistent with ECE measurements. Note that GTC finds that LFM as well as BAE is close to ideal MHD, i.e., ratio of parallel electric field to perpendicular one is small. Also note that BAE as well as LFM has large enough parallel magnetic perturbation, comparable to perpendicular one. Previous theoretical and simulation studies, not considering effects from strong drive, did not predict these features. Fig. 1. ALCON plot of n=3 MHD continua in the plasma frame, with BAE and LFM found in linear GTC.

'BAAE' Instabilities Observed Without Fast Ion Drive

Nonlinear Dynamics of Beta-Induced Alfvén Eigenmode in Tokamak

Excitation and Saturation of Low Frequency Alfven Eigenmodes

Theoretical Studies of Low-Frequency Shear Alfvén Waves in Reversed Shear Tokamak Plasmas

Linear Properties of Reversed Shear Alfvén Eigenmodes in the DIII-D Tokamak

Study Of Reversed Shear Alfven Eigenmodes With Down Sweeping Frequency In Hl-2a Experiment At Q(Min) Similar To 1

Experimental observation of low-frequency magnetohydrodynamic instabilities driven by energetic electrons in low hybrid current drive plasmas

Second Stable Regime of Internal Kink Modes Excited by Barely Passing Energetic Ions in Tokamak Plasmas

Drift Alfven energetic particle stability with circulating particles

Theoretical Studies of Low-Frequency Alfvén Modes in Tokamak Plasmas

Low-frequency Shear Alfven Waves at DIII-D: Theoretical Interpretation of Experimental Observations

Destabilization of low-frequency modes (LFMs) driven by thermal pressure gradient in EAST plasmas with q min ≤ 2

Isotope impact on Alfvén eigenmodes and fast ion transport in DIII-D

Destabilization of Beta-Induced Alfvén Eigenmodes by Energetic Trapped Electrons in Tokamak

Experimental Observation of Beta-Induced Alfvén Eigenmodes During Strong Tearing Modes on the EAST Tokamak in Fast-Electron Plasmas

Kinetic Electromagnetic Instabilities in an ITB Plasma with Weak Magnetic Shear

Bursting core-localized ellipticity-induced Alfvén eigenmodes driven by energetic electrons during EAST ohmic discharges

Hybrid simulations of beta-induced Alfvén eigenmode with reversed safety factor profile

Theoretical study of the Alfven Eigenmode stability in CFETR steady state discharges

The Response of Short-Scale Density Fluctuations to the Activity of Beta-Induced Alfvén Eigenmodes During Strong Tearing Modes on EAST Tokamak

Effect of the neutral beam injector operational regime on the Alfven eigenmode saturation phase in DIII-D plasma