Effects of Organic Farming on Diversity of Arthropods in Farmlands of North China Plain in Summer

HAN Yin,DAI Piaopiao,LI Xiang,SONG Xiao,LI Ji,LIU Yunhui

DOI: https://doi.org/10.11934/j.issn.1673-4831.2015.05.013

2015-01-01

Abstract:A field survey was carried out by sampling using pitfall trapping method to investigate diversity of soil surface arthropods in organic and conventional fields in Suning of Hebei and Gaotang and Caoxian of Shandong in the North China Plain. Comparison analysis was made of diversities at three taxonomic levels, such as the order of Arthropoda, the family of Coleoptera and the species of Carabidae, structural composition and distribution of different arthropod communities, rel?ative to farming pattern, organic or conventional, so as to evaluate effect of organic farming on biodiversity in farmlands and determine whether difference exists between evaluations using bioindicators different in taxonomic level. Results show that ( 1) in Caoxian County, organic fields were higher than conventional fields in abundance of Arthropoda at all the three taxonomic levels;in Gaotang County, it was so only in abundance of the suborder of Arthropoda and in Suning County, no big difference was found in abundance of Arthropoda at all the three taxonomic levels between the two farming patterns. ( 2) in terms of richness of Arthropoda, significant differences were found between the two farming patterns at the taxonom?ic levels of the family of Coleoptera and the species of Carabidae in Caoxian County only;besides, in terms of community structure, significant difference was found only in Caoxian County, partial difference in Gaotang County and nothing signif?icant in Suning County. On the whole, organic fields are much higher than conventional fields in biodiversity of the three groups of arthropods and differences exist between the two farming patterns in structure of arthropod communities in the soil surface. However, the differences between the variance with region and taxonomic level, which may be attributed to the number of years the fields have been under organic management. Evaluations of biodiversity in organic and conventional fields using bioindicators based on different taxonomic levels may differ slightly, but basically consistent in general trend, indicating that it is more advisable to use bioindicators based on high taxonomic level, e.g. the order of Arthropoda or the family of Coleoptera, to indicate effect of organic farming on environment, so as to reduce difficulty in classification and raise working efficiency. But bioindicators based on the taxonomic level of species of Carabidare are more sensitive to difference in biodiversity.