Synergistic Expression of the Abscopal Effect in a Murine Tumor Model Treated with Combined Radiation and Single or Dual-Immune Checkpoint Blockade

R. M. Shulman,T. Bagnyukova,L. Chen,X. Chen,H. Borghaei,J. E. Meyer
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijrobp.2022.07.2119
2020-01-01
Abstract:Retrospective clinical studies and case reports have found that the abscopal effect of radiotherapy (RT) may be increased by the addition of immunotherapy. This study sought further evidence for such a synergistic abscopal effect by combining RT and immunotherapy in a murine tumor model. Forty-two immunocompetent KRAS-LSL-G12D/+/p53KO mice were implanted with syngeneic KP-1 tumor cells in both the upper and lower back and randomized into seven groups. Group 1 controls were administered sham treatment. Group 2 received radiation with 8 Gy x 3 fractions delivered to the lower back tumors only. Groups 3 and 4 were given 250 μg of murine anti-PD-1 monoclonal antibody as either an intraperitoneal (IP) or intratumoral (IT) injection to lower back tumors only. Groups 5, 6 and 7 received both RT to the lower back tumors and anti-PD-1 antibody delivered either as an IP injection (250 μg) or an IT injection (250 μg or 500 μg) to lower back tumors only. Tumor growth was measured at both the non-irradiated (upper back) site and the irradiated (lower back) site. Irradiated lower back tumors demonstrated a smaller increase in mean tumor volume for mice receiving radiation (RT = 62 mm3) or RT and immunotherapy (RT+IP = 37 mm3, RT+ 250 μg IT = 37 mm3, RT + 500 μg IT = 84 mm3) than for mice receiving either no treatment (sham = 286 mm3, p <0.05) or anti-PD-1 antibody alone (IP = 155 mm3, 250 μg IT = 288 mm3; p < 0.05, Table 1). Immunotherapy alone did not alter the mean growth of non-irradiated upper back tumors (IP = 407 mm3, 250 μg IT = 643 mm3, sham = 559 mm3). The combination of RT with 250 μg IT anti-PD-1 antibody (but not 500 μg) produced decreased growth of upper back tumors from day 1 to day 11 (165 mm3 vs sham = 449 mm3, p = 0.018), an early trend which was reversed by an increase in upper back tumor volume from day 11 to day 15 (Table 1). For all groups, body weight did not change significantly throughout the trial. The results demonstrate a growth delay of murine KP-1 tumors when treated with RT alone or in combination with immunotherapy. Evidence for a synergistic abscopal effect is provided by an early trend toward improved control of non-irradiated tumors when lower-dose IT immunotherapy is combined with irradiation at a remote tumor site but not when either treatment is given alone.Abstract 3150; Table 1Mean tumor volume (mm3)Lower back tumor (irradiated)Upper back tumor (non-irradiated)Day14811151481115Control98144206283384228359517677787RT only155157150201217238309462619789IP104131187240259223266398442630IT105141227292393235400532732878RT + IP11611790130153223248362529785RT + 250 μg IT111109117106148217208257382614RT + 500 μg IT116109140148200207241320498622 Open table in a new tab
What problem does this paper attempt to address?