Abstract:Many applications of block designs exhibit neighbor and edge effects. A popular remedy is to use the circular design coupled with the interference model. The search for optimal or efficient designs has been intensively studied in recent years. The circular neighbor balanced designs at distances 1 and 2 (CNBD2), including orthogonal array of type I (OAI) of strength 2, are the two major designs proposed in literature for the purpose of estimating the direct treatment effects. They are shown to be optimal within some reasonable subclasses of designs. By using benchmark designs in approximate design theory, we show that CNBD2 is highly efficient among all possible designs when the error terms are homoscedastic and uncorrelated. However, when the error terms are correlated, these designs will be outperformed significantly by other designs. Note that CNBD2 fall into the special catalog of pseudo symmetric designs, and they only exist when the number of treatments is larger than the block size and the number of blocks is multiple of some constants. In this paper, we elaborate equivalent conditions for any design, pseudo symmetric or not, to be universally optimal for any size of experiment and any covariance structure of the error terms. This result is novel for circular designs and sheds light on other similar models in the search for optimal or efficient asymmetric designs.

Construction of some s-level regular designs with general minimum lower-order confounding

Construction of three-level factorial designs with general minimum lower-order confounding via resolution IV designs

GENERALIZED RESOLUTION AND MINIMUM ABERRATION CRITERIA FOR S LEVEL FACTORIAL DESIGNS

Construction of Optimal Mixed-Level Uniform Designs

Characterization of Three-Order Confounding Via Consulting Sets

sn−m Designs containing clear main effects or clear two-factor interactions

Theory Of Minimum Aberration Blocked Regular Mixed Factorial Designs

-Optimal Mixed-Level Supersaturated Designs

Optimal Mixed-Level Supersaturated Designs and a New Class of Combinatorial Designs

Optimal Foldover Plans for Regular S-Level Fractional Factorial Designs

Search for Minimum Aberration Designs with Uniformity

Minimum Secondary Aberration Fractional Factorial Split-Plot Designs in Terms of Consulting Designs

Characterization of Minimum Aberration Mixed Factorials in Terms of Consulting Designs

Minimum Aberration Blocking of Regular Mixed Factorial Designs

A Class of Multilevel Nonregular Designs for Studying Quantitative Factors

A complementary design theory for doubling

Mixed-level column augmented uniform designs

Optimal Criteria and Equivalence for Nonregular Fractional Factorial Designs

Identification Of Universally Optimal Circular Designs For The Interference Model

Sequential good lattice point sets for computer experiments

Connection among Some Optimal Criteria for Symmetrical Fractional Factorial Designs