Abstract:Rice paddies are a prominent contributor to greenhouse gases (GHGs) emissions, accounting for 22 % of the overall agricultural methane (CH4) emissions. Although returning rice straw to the field can increase yield and soil organic carbon (SOC), the significant GHGs released during this process often negate these positive effects. Thus, understanding the impact of straw returning on the relationship between rice yield and GHGs is crucial for farming adaptation and climate change mitigation. This study aims to investigate the effects of varying straw returning rates on rice yield and GHGs in China and identify the optimal rates on a provincial scale. This study utilized county-level meteorological, soil, and field management data. The Dynamic Nitrogen and Carbon Model (DNDC) model was used to simulate the impacts on rice yield, GHGs, and SOC changes under different straw returning rates in China from 2010 to 2022, including no straw, 1/3, 2/3, and full straw returning. The results showed that 1/3, 2/3, and full straw incorporation increased rice yield per unit area by 1.07 %, 2.25 %, and 3.26 % for single rice cropping, 1.10 %, 2.24 %, and 3.52 % for early rice, and 1.92 %, 3.91 %, and 5.95 % for late rice, respectively. Compared with no straw returning, the total SOC content (0–50 cm) increased by 3.88 % (78.07 Tg), 7.75 % (156.09 Tg), and 11.65 % (234.62 Tg) under 1/3, 2/3, and full straw returning, respectively. However, the total GHGs were increased by 23.32 %, 43.50 %, and 61.48 % for 1/3, 2/3, and full straw incorporation compared to no straw returning. While the overall benefits of straw returning varied across regions, in certain areas like northeastern China, Xinjiang, and Yunnan, an increase in straw returning rates leads to a significant increase in yield with a relatively smaller increase in GHGs. This can be attributed to factors such as lower temperatures, decreased SOC, and lower soil pH, restricting CH4 production. Conversely, in regions with higher soil pH, such as north China and the Sichuan Basin, as well as in warmer southern areas, the increase in GHGs is quite pronounced. In , implementing straw returning significantly increases rice production and SOC but simultaneously increases GHGs. In China, the most widespread utilization of rice straw remains straw returning. We have summarized the average impact of straw returning on yield, SOC, and GHGs, and proposed straw returning rates tailored to the comprehensive benefits in different regions, to enhance the carbon sequestration and emission reduction rate of rice straw returning.

Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Rice Straw Return Varies with Return Depth and Soil Type in Paddy Systems of Northeast China

Methane Emissions from Rice Fields under Continuous Straw Return in the Middle-Lower Reaches of the Yangtze River

Effects of continuous straw retention on the greenhouse gas emissions of rice-wheat fields in the middle-lower reaches of Yangtze River

Effects of Nitrogen Reduction and Optimized Fertilization Combined with Straw Return on Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Crop Yields of a Rice–Wheat Rotation System

An appropriate amount of straw replaced chemical fertilizers returning reduced net greenhouse gas emissions and improved net ecological economic benefits

Effects of long-term no tillage and straw return on greenhouse gas emissions and crop yields from a rice-wheat system in central China

Differences in responses of ammonia volatilization and greenhouse gas emissions to straw return and paddy-upland rotations

Appropriately Delayed Flooding Before Rice Transplanting Increases Net Ecosystem Economic Benefit in the Winter Green Manure-Rice Rotation System

Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Double-Season Rice Field under Different Tillage Practices and Fertilization Managements in Southeast China

Differences in methane and nitrous oxide emissions and soil bacteria communities between straw return methods in central China

Successive Years of Rice Straw Return Increased the Rice Yield and Soil Nutrients While Decreasing the Greenhouse Gas Intensity

RESIDUE MANAGEMENT AFFECTS GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS AND SOIL ORGANIC CARBON IN WHEAT-RICE ROTATION SYSTEM

Meta-analysis of GHG emissions stimulated by crop residue return in paddy fields: Strategies for mitigation

Methane emission under straw return is mitigated by tillage types depending on crop growth stages in a wheat-rotated rice farming system

Straw return alleviates the greenhouse effect of paddy fields by increasing soil organic carbon sequestration under water-saving irrigation

Straw Enhanced CO2 and CH4 but Decreased N2O Emissions from Flooded Paddy Soils: Changes in Microbial Community Compositions

Elevated [CO2] Reduces CH4 Emissions from Rice Paddies under in Situ Straw Incorporation

Optimizing the rate of straw returning to balance trade-offs between carbon emission budget and rice yield in China

[Effects of Aeration on Surface Water Nutrient Dynamics and Greenhouse Gas Emission in Different Straw Returning Paddy Fields].

Effects of Different Straw Returning Modes on Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Crop Yields in a Rice–wheat Rotation System

CH4 and N2O Emission and Grain Yield Performance of Three Main Rice-Farming Patterns in Central China