Abstract:Background: School-based law enforcement (SBLE) has become a common intervention. Although SBLE is meant to make schools safer, critics suggest it may not accomplish this purpose, and may have unintended negative consequences such as increasing students' exclusionary discipline or contact with the criminal justice system. There may also be secondary effects related to perceptions of the school or student learning. Objectives: The purpose of this review is to synthesize the literature evaluating the use of SBLE, including outcomes related to (a) crime and behavior problems; (b) perceptions of safety; and (c) learning. Methods: We conducted a systematic literature search to identify studies that examined outcomes associated with SBLE use. Eligible studies used experimental or quasi-experimental designs; included samples of students, teachers/staff, schools, or school districts; reported on a policing strategy focused on crime prevention or school safety that did not involve officers teaching a curriculum; included a measure that reflects crime and behavior problems, perceptions of safety, or learning; and were in a primary or secondary school. Following a multi-stage screening process to identify studies eligible for inclusion, we estimated a series of meta-analytic models with robust variance estimation to calculate weighted mean effect sizes for each of three main categories of outcomes and commonly occurring subsets of these categories. We examined heterogeneity in these estimates across features of the primary studies' design. Results: The search and screening process yielded 1002 effect sizes from 32 reports. There were no true experiments, and the quasi-experiments ranged from strictly correlational to permitting stronger causal inferences. SBLE use was associated with greater crime and behavior problems in studies that used schools as the unit of analysis. Within this category, SBLE use was associated with increased exclusionary discipline among studies that used both schools (g = 0.15, 95% confidence interval [CI] [0.02, 0.27]) and students (g = 0.003, 95% CI [0.002, 0.003]) as the unit of analysis. SBLE use was not associated with any measures of crime or violence in schools. SBLE use was associated with greater feelings of safety among studies that used schools as the unit of analysis (g = 0.18, 95% CI [0.13, 0.24]), although this estimate was based on only seven effect sizes from two correlational studies. All the other models, including those examining learning outcomes, yielded null results. None of the moderators tested showed meaningful relationships, indicating the findings were consistent across a variety of study design features. Authors’ conclusions: This study's findings provide no evidence that there is a safety-promoting component of SBLE, and support the criticism that SBLE criminalizes students and schools. Although we found no evidence of differences across methodological features, risk of bias in the primary studies limits our confidence in making causal inferences. To the extent that the findings are causal, schools that invest in strategies to improve safety will likely benefit from divesting from SBLE and instead investing in evidence-based strategies for enhancing school safety. Schools that continue to use SBLE should ensure that their model has no harmful effects and is providing safety benefits.

Factors Mediating School Safety in Charter Schools: an Analysis of Five Waves of Nationally Representative Data

The Relationship Between Parent Volunteering in School and School Safety in Disadvantaged Urban Neighborhoods

Structural Analysis of 1995–2005 School Crime Supplement Datasets: Factors Influencing Students' Fear, Anxiety, and Avoidant Behaviors

Blending in and standing out: College-going rates across charter and traditional public high schools

Strategies to promote safety for sexual and gender minority youth in secondary schools: A longitudinal analysis

Teacher Working Conditions, Teacher Commitment, and Charter Schools

Choice, Mobility, and Classification: Disaggregating the Charter School Special Education Gap

In Pursuit of the Common Good: The Spillover Effects of Charter Schools on Public School Students in New York City

A Longitudinal Examination of Gun Reporting by Middle and High-School Students

Individual and Contextual Factors Associated with Immigrant Youth Feeling Unsafe in School: A Social-Ecological Analysis

School Climate Counts: A Longitudinal Analysis of School Climate and Middle School Bullying Behaviors

Understanding the relationship between perceived school climate and bullying: A mediator analysis

Race, Bullying, and Public Perceptions of School and University Safety

Student Race, School Police, and the School-To-Prison Pipeline: Mixed Evidence of Indirect Pathways

How Community and Individual Risk Factors Mutually Impact Youth’s Perceived Safety: A Syndemic Analysis Using Structural Equation Modeling

A Paradox of School Social Organization: Positive School Climate, Friendship Network Density, and Adolescent Violence

School climate and bullying bystander responses in middle and high school

Staying Away From School

School-based law enforcement strategies to reduce crime, increase perceptions of safety, and improve learning outcomes in primary and secondary schools: A systematic review

College Student Perceptions of Campus Safety Initiatives