An investigation of strategic configurations and their impacts on performance of Chinese manufacturing companies

Zhiqiang Wang,Xiande Zhao,Chee-Chuong Sum

2006-01-01

Abstract:The impact of competitive strategy and operation strategy on firm performance has been a focus of research in recent years. Structural Contingency Theory has proposed that environment is one of the most important factors that influence the formulation of strategy. Many researchers of strategic management investigated the alignment between environment and strategy and its impact on the firm performance. Also, the alignment between competitive strategy and operations strategy is contended to be another important determinant of firm financial performance. In this paper, strategic configurations of environment uncertainty, competitive strategy and operation strategy are studied using configuration theory approaches. The impacts of strategic configurations on firm performance are tested by conceptualizing fit as profile deviation. External fit is defined as the competitive strategy fit with environment uncertainty. Internal fit is defined as the operation strategy fit with environment uncertainty and competitive strategy. An empirical study of 614 Chinese manufacturers is conducted to investigate the strategic configurations among environment uncertainty, competitive strategy and operation strategy, and their impacts on firm performance. This study validates some of the configurations developed in western strategy research. Similar patterns of strategic configurations are found in Chinese manufacturers. In general, deviation from the ideal patterns of strategic configurations would undermine firm financial performance. Specially, the results indicate that external fit and internal fit has different impacts on firm performance under different situations. One of the implications of this research is that managers should emphasize the external fit and internal fit differently when they face different situations in order to achieve better firm performance.