Abstract:Reputations are critical to human societies, as individuals are treated differently based on their social standing 1,2 . For instance, those who garner a good reputation by helping others are more likely to be rewarded by third parties 3,4,5 . Achieving widespread cooperation in this way requires that reputations accurately reflect behaviour 6 and that individuals agree about each other's standings 7 . With few exceptions 8,9,10 , theoretical work has assumed that information is limited, which hinders consensus 7,11 unless there are mechanisms to enforce agreement, such as empathy 12 , gossip 13,14,15 or public institutions 16 . Such mechanisms face challenges in a world where empathy, effective communication and institutional trust are compromised 17,18,19 . However, information about others is now abundant and readily available, particularly through social media. Here we demonstrate that assigning private reputations by aggregating several observations of an individual can accurately capture behaviour, foster emergent agreement without enforcement mechanisms and maintain cooperation, provided individuals exhibit some tolerance for bad actions. This finding holds for both first- and second-order norms of judgement and is robust even when norms vary within a population. When the aggregation rule itself can evolve, selection indeed favours the use of several observations and tolerant judgements. Nonetheless, even when information is freely accessible, individuals do not typically evolve to use all of it. This method of assessing reputations—'look twice, forgive once', in a nutshell—is simple enough to have arisen early in human culture and powerful enough to persist as a fundamental component of social heuristics.

Reputation, Cult of Reputation, and International Conflict

Reputation systems, aggression, and deterrence in social interaction

Coercion and Provocation

Reconciliation and the Remaking of Anarchy

Self-control of states: bridging social psychology to international relations discourses

Reputation, Identity and Organization Dynamics

A hostile reputation: A social network approach to interstate hostility

Revolutionary leaders and the punishment of critics

The Political Legacy of Violence During China's Cultural Revolution

Governments, publics, and enemies: Intragroup dynamics as barriers to conflict resolution

Reputation in Repeated Global Games of Regime Change with Exit

Reputation and the Realization of Collective Actions in the Chinese Relation-based Society

Cooperation and social organization depend on weighing private and public reputations

The democratic king: The role of ritualized flattery in political discourse

International System, not International Structure: Against the Agent-Structure Problematique in IR

The Politics, Power, and Pathologies of International Organizations

Credibility talk in public diplomacy

Beyond the enemy image and spiral model: cognitive–strategic research after the cold war

The evolution of private reputations in information-abundant landscapes

Linkage Politics in China: Internal Mobilization and Articulated External Hostility in the Cultural Revolution, 1967-1969

Harnessing the power of reputation: strengths and limits for promoting cooperative behaviors