Mutual Funds' Trading Behavior and Stock Market Volatility
ZHANG Zong-xin,ZHANG Xue-jiao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-6062.2012.02.022
2012-01-01
Abstract:Institutionalization of investors is the trend of the international stock the rapid growth of China's securities market,mutual funds,represented as institutional investors,have accounted for 40%~50% of capitalization and are having growing impact on the market.Influenced by the macro-economic cycle fluctuations and the global financial crisis,China's stock has experienced a rapid alternation between super bull market and bear market.With the emotion changing from frenzy to panic,the stock is experiencing volatile fluctuation.In this volatile environment,will the funds intensify or stabilize the market? Is Market volatility derived from systemic shocks or the adjustment of funds portfolio? Does the stock volatility caused by buying behavior of the funds have any relationships with the volatility of the stock market? How are these relationships established and whether they are predictable? These problems currently faced by China's securities are good representative of institutional investors. This paper selected the top ten heavily holding mutual funds between 2007 and 2009 as our samples.The sample is representative because it includes different industries and has different attributes.At the same time,we provide descriptive statistics of the sample according to the proportion of the funds recording the buying or selling behaviors in different stages. In this paper,the empirical study includes two parts.In the first part,we use wavelet analysis to study the volatility of samples' features at different stages from the micro-level.Empirical results show that the stock's volatility will decline when the funds increase or maintain a ware-house stock rate but increase when the funds decrease in the non-symmetric market.Specifically,heavy-weight stocks,such as China Vanke Co.Ltd,are influenced by the fund severely,adding more in the portfolio stabilized fluctuations with less noise trading.On the other hand,introducing herding behaviors to a certain degree can still interfere the sentiment,increase volatility,and create noise in the training process. Although the volatility of the counter-cyclical stocks,such as the Hei Longjiang Agriculture Co.,Ltd,increases when the funds reduce proportion,noise will increase even when the funds add proportion,which is mainly due to its agricultural characteristics.This condition makes these kinds of stocks susceptible to weather factors,which can cause noise trading frequently throughout the year.As for the small-cap growth stocks,such as Beijng Gehua CATV Netwok Co.,Ltd,it is vulnerable to the impact of large trading volume.In addition investors' different opinions on its future growth can lead to the valuation bias.Thus,volatility will increase regardless whether the funds increase or decrease.In addition,the growth uncertainty can cause low participation of small and medium investors and result in relatively small noise trading.All of our samples can be attributed to these three kinds of stocks.In the second part,we analyze the financial market's level.Firstly we test the spillover effect by applying the regression equation between two time-series variables.The results show that there is a certain relationship between the volatility of the stocks and the stock market,even though the effect is not significant(R2is low).Thus we consider using of cross-spectral analysis,which is also very effective on the high-frequency data and can test the inter-relation of time series from a wave aspect.The finding indicates that there is a weak relationship between data(Coherency Spectrum coefficient is low),suggesting that the adjustment of the funds' portfolio may cause the volatility,and the volatility has little effect on stocks' volatility.