Abstract:<p>A two-dimensional tumor-immune model with the time delay of the adaptive immune response is considered in this paper. The model is designed to account for the interaction between cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) and cancer cells on the surface of a solid tumor. The model considers the surface growth as a major growth pattern of solid tumors in order to describe the existence of necrotic kernels. The qualitative analysis shows that the immune-free equilibrium is unstable, and the behavior of positive equilibrium is closely related to the ratio of the immune killing rate to tumor volume growth rate. The positive equilibrium is locally asymptotically stable when the ratio is smaller than a critical value. Otherwise, the occurrence of the delay-driven Hopf bifurcation at the positive equilibrium is proved. Applying the center manifold reduction and normal form method, we obtain explicit formulas to determine the properties of the Hopf bifurcation. The global continuation of a local Hopf bifurcation is investigated based on the coincidence degree theory. The results reveal that the time of the adaptive immune system taken to response to tumors can lead to oscillation dynamics. We also carry out detailed numerical analysis for parameters and numerical simulations to illustrate our qualitative analysis. Numerically, we find that shorter immune response time can lead to longer patient survival time, and the period and amplitude of a stable periodic solution increase with the increasing immune response time. When CTLs recruitment rate and death rate vary, we show how the ratio of the immune killing rate to tumor volume growth rate and the first bifurcation value change numerically, which yields further insights to the tumor-immune dynamics.</p>

Existence and bifurcation of non-constant positive steady states for a tumor–immune model

Stability and Bifurcation Analysis of a Tumor-Immune System with Two Delays and Diffusion

Bifurcation and Pattern Formation of a Tumor–immune Model with Time-Delay and Diffusion

Bifurcation analysis of a free boundary problem modelling tumour growth under the action of inhibitors

Analysis of a mathematical model for tumor growth with Gibbs–Thomson relation

Spatial Patterns and Bifurcation Analysis of a Diffusive Tumour-immune Model

Asymptotic Behavior of Solutions of a Free Boundary Problem Modeling the Growth of Tumors with Fluid-Like Tissue under the Action of Inhibitors

Stationary Solutions of a Free Boundary Problem Modeling the Growth of Tumors with Gibbs–Thomson Relation

Hopf Bifurcation Induced by Delay Effect in a Diffusive Tumor-Immune System.

Bifurcations of Tumor-Immune Competition Systems with Delay

Modeling the Nonmonotonic Immune Response in a Tumor–Immune System Interaction

Longtime evolution and stationary response of a stochastic tumor-immune system with resting T cells

A NONLINEAR DELAY MODEL DESCRIBING THE GROWTH OF TUMOR CELLS UNDER IMMUNE SURVEILLANCE AGAINST CANCER AND ITS STABILITY ANALYSIS

Bifurcations in Delay Differential Equations and Applications to Tumor and Immune System Interaction Models.

Mathematical modeling of tumor surface growth with necrotic kernels

Global well‐posedness and long‐time behavior in a tumor invasion model with cross‐diffusion

Dynamics and Stability of a Fractional-Order Tumor–Immune Interaction Model with B-D Functional Response and Immunotherapy

Dynamics Analysis of a Diffusional Immunosuppressive Infection Model with Beddington-DeAngelis Functional Response

Mathematical Analysis on a Diffusion Model Describing the Compatibility Between Two Types of Tumor Cells

Global Dynamics of the Model of Tumor-Immune Interaction

Oscillations in a tumor-immune system interaction model with immune response delay