Abstract:There hasn't been much exchange of ideas between economists and philosophers of economics. This is understandable to some extent, given that the primary focus of these communities is different. Most economists show little interest in the general and abstract methodological issues that philosophers of economics typically explore, for example, and conversely most philosophers of economics do not seem to be very interested in the practical, 'bread and butter' decisions that pre-occupy economists in their professional practices. But there are exceptions, such as the series of papers Itzhak Gilboa, Andrew Postlewaite, Larry Samuelson, and David Schmeidler (GPSS) have been publishing on how economists think about their own modelling practices (Gilboa et al., Citation 2014 , Citation 2018 , Citation 2019 , Citation 2023 ). These papers for sure fall within the orbit of interest of philosophers of economics. Yet direct and explicit engagement with the work of GPSS by philosophers of economics has been largely missing. When we saw a working paper by GPSS on economic methodology circulating some three years ago, we thought that it would provide a nice opportunity to organize an open exchange with prominent philosophers of economics. Hence, we contacted GPSS to invite them to submit this as a target article for a special issue. Although this working paper was submitted to another journal (Gilboa et al. Citation 2023 ), GPSS kindly offered to write a new article for JEM, outlining their views. After their article was published online, we invited a diverse set of authors with expertise on this topic to provide commentaries. Many of those invited graciously agreed to submit their commentary. While the process, including submission of the articles and peer review, took longer than anticipated, we are proud to present this special issue at the end of 2024.

Special Issue: Second and Third Best Theories: Criticisms and Applications Editors' Introduction

Second-best congestion pricing models for multiple time periods and multiple travelers

A theory of best choice selection through objective arguments grounded in Linear Response Theory concepts

Teacher Labor Market Policy and the Theory of the Second Best

Second-Guessing Theory: Review and Extension

‘ ‘ Best Practices ’ ’ Research : AMethodological Guide for the Perplexed Stuart Bretschneider

Maximin Justice, Sacrifice, and the Reciprocity Argument: A Pragmatic Reassessment of the Rawls/Nozick Debate

Insider apology for microeconomic theorising?

Second-order productivity, second-order payoffs, and the Banzhaf value

Theoretical Visions Versus Policymaking Realities? Searching For The Logical Grounds Of Expansion And Retrenchment Arguments In Studies On Nordic Social Policy Models From The 1960s To The 2000s

Policy equipoise and interventional superiority

Trade Policy in a Third‐Country Model With Kantian Optimization

The Second Generation of International Political Economy's Background Characteristics and Theories Beyond

Introduction to the special issue: economic theories and their dueling interpretations

Regret theory and the competitive firm: A comment

Haves and Have-Nots: A Theory of Economic Sufficientarianism

Comments on Theories of Other-regarding Preferences

Let the Best 'one' Win: Policy Lessons from the New Economics of Platforms

Second‐best socially optimal R&D under output spillovers

In-itself for-itself: Towards second-generation neo-Marxist class theory

Prospect Theory and Foreign Policy Decision-making