Abstract:The selection of a data processing method for use in mass spectrometry-based label-free proteome quantification contributes significantly to its accuracy and precision. In this study, we comprehensively evaluated 7 commonly-used label-free quantification methods (MaxQuant-Spectrum count, MaxQuant-iBAQ, MaxQuant-LFQ, MaxQuant-LFAQ, Proteome Discoverer, MetaMorpheus, TPP-StPeter) with a focus on missing values, precision, accuracy, selectivity, and reproducibility of low abundance protein quantification in both single shot and fractionation. Our results showed that among the tested strategies, MaxQuant in MaxLFQ mode outperformed other strategies in terms of accuracy and precision in both whole proteome and low abundance proteome quantification, whereas the Proteome Discoverer (PD) strategy using SEQUEST as a search engine performed better in terms of quantifiable low abundance proteome coverage. We subsequently applied the PD and MaxLFQ strategies in a blood proteomic dataset and found that many FDA-approved tumor prognostic biomarkers could be identified as well as quantified using the PD strategy, indicating the potential advantage of PD in label-free quantification studies. These results provide a reference for method choice in label-free quantification data analysis. SIGNIFICANCE: Mass spectrometry-based label-free quantification methods play an important role in label-free proteome data analysis. In this study, we evaluated 7 commonly-used label-free quantification methods with respect to the following aspects: missing values, precision, accuracy, selectivity, and reproducibility for low abundance protein quantification. The results showed that, among the strategies evaluated, the PD strategy with SEQUEST as a search engine performed better in terms of low abundance protein coverage. This study provides a reference for method choice in label-free quantification data analysis.

Development of Absolute Quantification of Proteome Based on Isotope Dilution

Comparative evaluation of label-free quantification strategies.

Relative And Absolute Quantitation In Mass Spectrometry-Based Proteomics

A new sample preparation method for the absolute quantitation of a target proteome using (18)O labeling combined with multiple reaction monitoring mass spectrometry

Amino Acid Residue Specific Stable Isotope Labeling for Quantitative Proteomics

High-throughput Absolute Quantification of Proteins Using an Improved Two-Dimensional Reversed-Phase Separation and Quantification Concatemer (qconcat) Approach.

Absolute quantification methods for Prostate-Specific antigen by Isotope-Dilution mass spectrometry

Peptide Biosynthesis with Stable Isotope Labeling from a Cell-free Expression System for Targeted Proteomics with Absolute Quantification

A Mass Spectrometry Strategy for Protein Quantification Based on the Differential Alkylation of Cysteines Using Iodoacetamide and Acrylamide

Single Isotopologue for In-Sample Calibration and Absolute Quantitation by LC-MS/MS

Absolute protein quantification based on calibrated particle counting using electrospray-differential mobility analysis

Improvement Of The Quantification Accuracy And Throughput For Phosphoproteome Analysis By A Pseudo Triplex Stable Isotope Dimethyl Labeling Approach

Standard-Free Absolute Quantitation of Antibody Deamidation Degradation and Host Cell Proteins by Coulometric Mass Spectrometry

Label--free Protein Quantification Methods in Proteomics Research

A Novel Quantitative Proteomics Workflow by Isobaric Terminal Labeling.

Label-free absolute protein quantification with data-independent acquisition.

An optimised method to isotopically label pure synthetic peptides 'in-house' for absolute quantification in bottom-up proteomics

LFAQ: Toward Unbiased Label-Free Absolute Protein Quantification by Predicting Peptide Quantitative Factors

Absolute Quantification of Cytochrome P450 and Uridinediphosphate Glucuronosyl Transferase Isoforms by Proteomics-based Approach

A Systematic N-terminal Peptide Quantitative Labeling Strategy for Differential Proteomic Analysis.

Amino Acid-Coded Tagging Approaches in Quantitative Proteomics