Abstract:Projecting the course of infectious diseases and assessing the likely impact of policies to contain them require reliable estimates of the parameters in dynamic models of disease transmission. However, such estimation is difficult, especially for emerging diseases such as COVID-19, due to incomplete and delayed data, measurement error, and model specification error. Absent reliable estimation, model-based recommendations could be misleading. Here we conduct synthetic data experiments comparing the performance of various estimation methods for calibrating epidemic models, considering both process and measurement noise. We compare the performance of standard least squares against maximum likelihood methods including scaled-variance Gaussian, Poisson, and negative binomial likelihood functions, and assess the effectiveness of (extended) Kalman filtering. We explore the performance of these methods under different assumptions about data availability, from full information on the infection, symptom emergence, and removal rates to the more realistic setting where data are available only for symptom emergence. We find that widely-adopted naive estimation methods (least squares or incomplete Gaussian likelihood, without variance scaling and without Kalman filtering) perform poorly, especially in the estimation of confidence intervals. The negative binomial likelihood function performs well across a range of assumptions, scaling the error variance and Kalman filtering improve performance over the basic Gaussian estimator. We provide modelers with guidance to help choose estimation methods appropriate for their problem setting and data. Results may inform problems beyond the epidemic context, from models of innovation diffusion to other feedback-rich managerial and policy settings with limited data, process noise, and measurement error.

Imprecise Parameters for Near-Optimal Control of Stochastic SIV Epidemic Model

Near-optimal control of a stochastic SICA model with imprecise parameters

Finite horizon optimal control of reaction-diffusion SIV epidemic system with stochastic environment

Control of SIR Epidemics: Sacrificing Optimality for Feasibility

Dynamical behavior and optimal control of a stochastic SAIRS epidemic model with two saturated incidences

Optimal control and dynamics of a nonlocal diffusion SVIR epidemic model

Optimal control for virus spreading for an SIR model

A deterministic SAIR model with vaccination and treatment: dynamical behaviors and control strategies

Optimal Mitigation of SIR Epidemics Under Model Uncertainty

Disease X epidemic control using a stochastic model and a deterministic approximation: Performance comparison with and without parameter uncertainties

Stability and Optimality Criteria for an SVIR Epidemic Model with Numerical Simulation

Dynamic characterization of control SIR-type systems and optimal single-interval control

Optimal Control of Vaccination Game Based on Fuzzy Convex Parameter Method

Global dynamics of a non-smooth SIV system with uncertain effective vaccine protection rate

A state-dependent impulsive system with ratio-dependent action threshold for investigating SIR model

Optimal Control for an Epidemic Model of COVID-19 with Time-Varying Parameters

Numerical Simulation Method For The Siv Epidemic Model With Impulsive Vaccination And Infection-Age

Random dynamics of an SIV epidemic model

Optimality of vaccination for an SIR epidemic with an ICU constraint

Improving Parameter Estimation of Epidemic Models: Likelihood Functions and Kalman Filtering

On Optimal Control at the Onset of a New Viral Outbreak