Efficient Evaluation and Decision-Making for Interactive Modes in Manufacturing: a Reliable Hybrid Method
Peng Nie,Xia Li,Liqiu Gao,Jichao Wu,Zhen Ma,Ganglong Zhao,Zohaib Aziz,He Xu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-024-14489-5
IF: 3.563
2024-01-01
The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology
Abstract:As human–machine interaction (HMI) technology advances, new interaction modes such as gesture and touch interactions are increasingly integrated into manufacturing facilities. These modern methods present unique benefits and drawbacks compared to traditional button interaction. Yet, there is a notable absence of a comprehensive quantitative evaluation method for selecting device interaction modes. This paper introduces a systematic approach to address this gap. Firstly, a multi-criteria evaluation system is established based on commonly used evaluation metrics for human–machine teams. We then employ a hybrid multi-criteria decision-making (HMCDM) method that combines subjective weighting from the rank correlation analysis (G1) method with the VIKOR method. This method provides a clear decision ordering for various interaction modes. When applied to evaluate three interaction modes in an assembly facility, our results suggest that button interaction is the most effective, scoring S(0.115), R(0.046), and Q(0.000). This finding aligns with results from other HMCDM methods, validating the reliability of the proposed HMCDM approach. Our method serves as a reliable guide for operators in choosing interaction modes and offers designers a foundation for further optimization.