Abstract:Chinese education is controversial: it is not only lauded for Chinese students’ high test achievements but also criticized for curbing students’ deep learning and development into well-rounded individuals. In the current paper, we propose that self-determination theory (SDT) serves as a useful framework for anatomizing Chinese educational ecology, especially understanding the fundamental developmental costs behind Chinese students’ high test scores. In the first part, we provide an up-to-date overview of SDT, which proposes that a growth-oriented motivation fueled by basic psychological needs underlies human development; hence, the role of education is to provide environmental support for these needs. After reviewing research evidence, we conclude that SDT serves as a valid theoretical framework for analyzing Chinese education. In the second part, we apply the lens of SDT to better understand the motivational dynamics that prevail in Chinese education. In doing so, we first primarily focus on the distal institutional level, thereby examining in detail how the high-stakes testing system headed by Gaokao fails to support—and may even thwart—basic psychological needs; we also address counterarguments favoring Gaokao, such as heightened involvement and alignment. We then scrutinize the pros and cons at the proximal level of the student environment—i.e., teachers and parents. Finally, we discuss existing reform attempts, which seemingly have very limited effectiveness. We propose that awareness of the problem and more holistic change are needed to realize more effective and sustainable change in Chinese education.

Social Darwinism, Status Ranking, and Creativity in Confucian-Heritage Education: Dialectics Between Education and Knowledge Economies

Creativity and Social Alienation: the Costs of Being Creative

Deyu as moral education in modern China: Ideological functions and transformations

Understanding higher vocational education in China: Vocationalism vs confucianism

Hope and Creative Self-Efficacy as Sequential Mediators in the Relationship Between Family Socioeconomic Status and Creativity

The Challenges of Implementing Diverse Political Directives in Contemporary China: Between Creativity and Confucianism

Political Culture and Higher Education Governance in Chinese Societies: Some Reflections

Education And The Reconstruction Of Chinese Society In The Globalized World

The Paradox of Educational Fairness in China

The Contemporary Issues in Chinese Education

Moral Education and Ideology: The Revival of Confucian Values and the Harmonious Shaping of the New Chinese Man

Ethnic Education Should Undertake the Major Historic Task of Ethnic Unity and the Possibility of and Explorations into the Localization of Diversified Education

Cultural Capital and Higher Education Inequalities in Contemporary China

The Phenomena of "Education Involution" and the Root Cause Cracking

To Build the Educational Objective "Ti-Yong Consistency" in the Multicultural Environment

Intra‐Asian Creativity in Hong Kong Education and Activism

How Does a Historical System of Meaning Weigh on the Present? Social Representations of Confucianism and Their Role in Young Chinese Lives in the People’s Republic of China

Unlocking the Creative Potential of Chinese New Liberal Arts: The Role of Interdisciplinary Education, Knowledge Integration, and Metacognitive Awareness

Educational discipline, ritual governing, and Chinese exemplary society: Why China’s curriculum reform remains a difficult task

Chinese Education Examined via the Lens of Self-Determination

The Divergence between Knowledge and Faith: Debates about the Religionization and Epistemologization of Confucianism in Modern Social Change