CHINA: THE AGING GIANT WITH AN ACHILLES HEEL

XinQi Dong,Melissa A. Simon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1532-5415.2007.01515.x

2008-01-01

Journal of the American Geriatrics Society

Abstract:To the Editor: We laud Flaherty and colleague's thoughtful article and important contribution to the sparse literature on Chinese aging.1 The authors described the strong family and community support that Chinese provide for older people. One of us having spent most of his life in a multigenerational household in a Chinese village, for the most part, we agree with the author's statement, but there is evidence that family and community support has weakened, and China now is at the crossroad of traditional values and Western influences. Confucian principles, which profoundly emphasize filial piety, which provides guidelines regarding power, roles, and duties of individual family members, have heavily influenced Chinese cultural values.2 The core of filial piety is based on the idea that individual lives and family members are not separate but are one entity. More specifically, it stresses that one should provide for the material and mental well-being of one's aged parents, perform ritual duties to worship ancestors, take care to avoid harm to one's body, ensure the continuity of the blood line, and practice self-discipline to preserve nobility and avoid disgrace to the family name. Parents are expected to care for their children when they are young, and adult children are expected to provide care for their parent when the parents grow old. For thousands of years, this tradition of interdependence among family members has sustained Chinese society. There is evidence that the younger generations are less adherent to the principles of filial piety. Elderly Chinese may no longer be guaranteed prestige, power, and care in the family.3 Recently, there has been a major shift of the younger workforce from rural areas to cities, which has broken millions of multigenerational households. Social changes brought about by urbanization and Western influences have posed many challenges to the traditional Chinese family relationships and roles. Younger generations are now exposed to diverse Western values in addition to traditional Chinese values. Many prefer to pursue individual development instead of fulfilling their prescribed social and familial duties. Furthermore, because of technological and medical advances, life expectancy is higher, yet many Chinese do not have pensions or retirement incomes. This has resulted in progressively greater physical and financial dependency on their children. Elder mistreatment is still very much uncharted in Chinese society, most likely due to a low level of societal awareness; elderly people's disinclination to reveal it in order to preserve family peace, dignity, and honor; and the perception that elder mistreatment is a private family affair and ought not to be revealed to the public. Traditional Chinese sayings include: “every family has difficulties, and outsiders should not meddle with other's family affairs” and “one should not hang dirty laundry in public.” These concepts and traditions might explain reluctance to disclose family matters. The pressure to preserve family honor and to protect the abuser is often cited in explaining the reluctance of Chinese to report child and spousal abuse.4, 5 We conducted a community survey in China and found that 35.2% of participants screened positive for elder mistreatment.6 Caregiver neglect was the most common (16.7%), followed by financial exploitation (13.6%), psychological mistreatment (11.4%), physical mistreatment (5.8%), sexual mistreatment (1.8%), and abandonment (0.4%). Of those who suffered from mistreatment, 64% suffered from a single form of mistreatment, 16% suffered from two forms of mistreatment, and 20% suffered from three different forms of elder mistreatment. Our other studies have shown that depression and loneliness are common in this Chinese population, and both are associated with greater risk for elder mistreatment.7, 8 Our study in Mainland China was similar to Hong Kong studies that found a prevalence of elder mistreatment of 21.4%.9 A recent qualitative study of Chinese elderly people further suggests that disrespect and isolation are prominently represented, and many considered it as a violation of traditional Chinese cultural values.10 These alarming statistics are further evidence of the traditional value system being threatened in contemporary Chinese society. Elder mistreatment was once thought to be an unthinkable phenomenon in Chinese culture. Now, “dirty linen” can no longer be hidden, and older individuals are voicing the suffering of their mistreatment and violation of their traditions, cultural customs, and human rights. As glorious as China has been, elder mistreatment is a pervasive public health issue for which the government needs to establish national definitions, reporting laws, practice, and policy that have a real effect on the local social services agencies. Culturally sensitive educational efforts are also needed to acknowledge the problem of elder mistreatment. These efforts must also be conjoined with rigorous research in understanding prevalence, incidence, risk and protective factors, and health outcomes of elder mistreatment in Chinese population. Conflict of Interest: The editor in chief has reviewed the financial and personal conflict of interest checklist and has determined that neither of the authors has any conflicts of interest related to this paper. Author Contributions: Drs. Dong and Simon both contributed to study concept and design, acquisition of subjects and data, analysis and interpretation of data, and preparation of the letter. Sponsor's Role: None.