Influence of incubation time on phosphorus sorption dynamics in lake sediments
Lidong Huang,Lingling Li,Lichun Huang,Gerty Gielen,Yongsong Zhang,Hailong Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11368-011-0455-z
IF: 3.5361
2011-01-01
Journal of Soils and Sediments
Abstract:Purpose Estimating phosphorus (P) sorption is generally achieved by measuring a decrease in P concentration over a defined period. However, information within the literature has not been able to be widely applied, probably due to the variability in incubation periods and initial P concentrations in reported experiments. The objective of this study was to investigate whether variations in incubation time and initial P concentration might result in differences in measured levels of P sorption in sediments. Materials and methods Sediments were collected from four eutrophic lakes (Hua, Mei, Gong and Dong) in eastern China. Sorption kinetics were measured over a 360-h incubation period. Isotherm sorption experiments were conducted over two incubation periods (24 h and 360 h) and three initial P ranges (0–5 mg l −1 , 0–20 mg l −1 and 0–100 mg l −1 ). Results and discussion The longer incubation period (360 h) and increased levels of initial P resulted in increased sorption maxima ( S max ). Fit to the Langmuir model decreased with an increase in the range of initial P concentration. The Freundlich model provided a better fit for the isotherm data than the Langmuir model. Desorption of freshly sorbed P with triplicate P-free water solution indicated that the longer incubation period facilitated the net retention of P. Loosely bound P, aluminum-bound P and iron-bound P were the most predominant P pools. Overall, the Mei, Gong and Dong sediments showed much larger P sorption potential and lower levels of labile P than Hua sediments. The P sorption reaction was a continuous process. The amount of sorption determined at any given time may be underestimated under conditions when the sorption rate was not negligible and sorption equilibrium had not been reached. As a consequence, experimental conditions in sorption studies such as time and initial concentration could, therefore, influence observed results. Conclusions Differences in incubation period and initial P concentration resulted in different sorption outcomes in these sorption experiments. These differences are likely to lead to difficulties when comparing results obtained under different experimental conditions. It is, therefore, recommended that experimental conditions need to be designed to ensure that sorption equilibria have been reached. It is recommended that standardized procedures be used for studies designed to determine P sorption.