Comparison of Diagnostic Criteria of Tc-99m-MDP Three-Phase Bone Scintigraphy to Identify Peri-Prosthetic Infection in Patients with Painful Total Knee Arthroplasty

Yuan Li,Qian Wang

2018-01-01

Abstract:114 Background: Three-phase bone scintigraphy (TPBS) is a cheap and convenient modality to distinguish peri-prosthetic infection from aseptic loosening. However, by using different diagnostic criteria, previous studies showed the diagnostic value of TPBS was controversal, especially in total knee arthroplasties (TKAs). This study retrospectively reviewed TPBS data of consecutive cases of patients with painful TKAs to investigate the proper diagnostic criteria of TPBS. Methods: We retrospectively reviewed 113 consecutive patients with painful TKAs underwent 99mTc-MDP TPBS to exclude peri-prosthetic infection. In these patients, total of 176 knee joints were replaced. Of these 176 joints, 117 were symptomatic and 59 were asymptomatic. Blood flow, blood pool and bone images were acquired immediately, 5 minutes and 4 hours after intravenous administration of 99mTc-MDP. Images were first interpreted visually and abnormal uptakes were recorded. To diagnose peri-prosthetic infection, three visual diagnostic criteria were compared: ①positive in blood flow and blood pool image; ②positive in bone image; ③positive in all three phases image. By delineating peri-prosthetic knee joint area as target region of interest (T) and mid-thigh area as background (B) in blood pool image, semi-quantitive analysis was applied and T/B value was calculated. Clinical diagnosis of peri-prosthetic infection was based on the visibly purulent synovial fluid found in the joint or surrounding area, positive culture obtained by joint aspiration or surgery, or acute inflammation confirmed by histopathologic findings. All of the patients were followed up over six months. The findings of TPBS were correlated with clinical diagnosis and the diagnostic efficacy of different criteria was compared. Results: In 117 cases symptomatic joints, 72 cases were clinically diagnosed as peri-prosthetic infection, and the other 45 cases diagnosed as aseptic loosening. According to visual interpretation of TPBS in asymptomatic joints, 17 of 58 cases (29.3%) showed abnormal uptake in blood flow and blood pool image and 10 of 58 cases (17.2%) showed abnormal uptake in bone image. To diagnose peri-prosthetic infection in symptomatic joints, three visual diagnostic criteria showed no significant difference in diagnostic efficacy. The highest accuracy among the three visual criteria was 73.5% (86/117). In semi-quantitive analysis, the average T/B value of infectious joints was higher than aseptic loosening joints (1.79±0.37 vs 1.11±0.23, t=12.172,P