Technoeconomic and Environmental Analysis of Ethylene Glycol Production from Coal and Natural Gas Compared with Oil-Based Production

Qing Yang,Qingchun Yang,Simin Xu,Shun Zhu,Dawei Zhang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.123120
IF: 11.1
2020-01-01
Journal of Cleaner Production
Abstract:Increasing demand of ethylene glycol conflicts with the shortage of supply, forcing Chinese government to seek for its alternative production routes. Recently, many coal-to-ethylene glycol (CTEG) and natural gas to ethylene glycol (NGTEG) plants have been successfully operated. It is an urgent work to answer the question: compared with the conventional oil to ethylene glycol (OTEG) route, is it an opportunity or a challenge for the development of coal and natural gas alternative technologies? In this paper, the technical, economic and environmental performance of these two alternative technologies are assessed to quantify their opportunities and challenges in comparison with conventional OTEG route. Results show that the coal-based route has a significant cost advantage, however, it suffers from high energy consumption, low exergy efficiency, serious CO2 emissions and wastewater discharge. The technical and environmental performances of the natural gas-based route are better than those of coal-based route, but its total production cost and internal rate of return are worse than those of coal-based route process. Finally, several suggestions are proposed to improve the comprehensive performance of the two alternative processes.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?