Freight Revenue Robust Optimization for Container Liner Shipping Considering Vessel Sailing Speed Deviation
LI De-chang,YANG Hua-long,SONG Wei,ZHENG Jian-feng
DOI: https://doi.org/10.16381/j.cnki.issn1003-207x.2020.1298
2023-01-01
Abstract:Container liner shipping is an important backbone for international trade marine transportation of industry products and general consumer goods. It has the characteristics of numerous and scattered customers, many kinds of high value goods with frequent transportation and strong timeliness. In order to meet customers’ transportation service requirements, shipping companies need to provide round-trip liner shipping services. They usually employ a certain number of containerships on the designed shipping route to visit each port of call punctually on a weekly basis. Due to the susceptibility to various uncertain factors such as bad weather, bad sea conditions and harsh route environment, the actual sailing speed of the containership in each leg often deviates from the planned one. This will not only change the fuel consumption of the containership in each leg, but also affect the voyage fuel cost and freight revenue. Therefore, it is of great practical significance to study the revenue optimization of container liner shipping considering the sailing speed deviation.In container liner shipping, the fuel consumption of containership is approximately proportional to the cubic of its sailing speed. When the containership slows down due to the influence of uncertain factors in a certain period of navigation, the captain needs to speed up in the remaining navigation period in order to arrive at the next port of call on schedule. The uncertainty adjustments of sailing speed will directly change the fuel consumptions and the oil tank reserves of the containership in each leg during the round trip. The changes in oil tank reserves will in turn affect the changes in cargo shipments in each OD flows during the round trip. In addition, there are differences in fuel prices and discount rates at various refueling ports, as well as the OD flows of container cargoes and their freight rates. Therefore, in order to ensure the safety of fuel use for containership in each leg during the round trip, shipping companies need to optimize voyage refueling and cargo shipment strategy according to the worst case of voyage sailing speed deviation, so as to achieve the robust optimization goal of the shipping company’s revenue.In view of this, the explicit function of the maximum fuel consumption in each leg is derived under the worst case of sailing speed deviation taking the time window of the containership’s arrival at the next port of call as the constraint. Furthermore, the impact of the differences in fuel prices and discounts in various bunkering ports, as well as the differences in OD flows and freight rates of containerized cargo on containership refueling and cargo shipping strategies is analyzed. Then a mixed integer non-linear programming model of robust revenue optimization for container shipping companies is established with the consideration of sailing speed deviation. The piecewise linear secant approximation algorithm is designed to solve the model. A number of numerical experiments are conducted for the real liner service route-MEX liner shipping route that serviced by CHINA COSCO SHIPPING GROUP.The research results show that the global robust optimization strategy for liner shipping refueling and cargo shipment considering sailing speed deviation can ensure containership navigation safety in each leg of voyage. Meanwhile, it also helps to achieve robust optimization of shipping company freight revenue. The sensitivity analysis results indicate that with the increase of the fuel consumption coefficient and the extreme deviation value of sailing speed in each leg of voyage, the fuel consumption of containership will also increase, and the freight revenue will decrease accordingly. The meaningful management enlightenments obtained from the research conclusions are as follows: 1) Shipping companies should combine the differences of fuel price and its discount at various refueling ports, as well as the differences in OD flow and freight rate, to formulate a global robust optimization strategy for refueling and cargo shipment under the worst case of sailing speed deviation and determine the minimum safe fuel storage in tanks for each leg of voyage based on this. Ensure the safety of oil used for navigation. 2)When shipping companies deploy different types of containerships with different fuel consumption coefficients on different routes that having different extreme values of sailing speed deviation to engage in liner shipping services, they need to perform global robust optimization for their refueling and cargo shipment strategies to achieve the goal of revenue maximization.