Utility of single versus sequential measurements of risk factors for prediction of stroke in Chinese adults
Junshi Chen,Zhengming Chen,Robert Clarke,Rory Collins,Yu Guo,Liming Li,Jun Lv,Richard Peto,Robin Walters,Daniel Avery,Derrick Bennett,Ruth Boxall,Fiona Bragg,Sushila Burgess,Kahung Chan,Yumei Chang,Yiping Chen,Zhengming Chen,Robert Clarke,Huaidong Du,Zammy Fairhurst-Hunter,Simon Gilbert,Alex Hacker,Parisa Hariri,Michael Holmes,Andri Iona,Becky Im,Maria Kakkoura,Christiana Kartsonaki,Rene Kerosi,Kuang Lin,Iona Millwood,Qunhua Nie,Alfred Pozaricki,Paul Ryder,Sam Sansome,Dan Schmidt,Rajani Sohoni,Rebecca Stevens,Iain Turnbull,Robin Walters,Lin Wang,Neil Wright,Ling Yang,Xiaoming Yang,Pang Yao,Yu Guo,Xiao Han,Can Hou,Chao Liu,Jun Lv,Pei Pei,Canqing Yu,Chun Li,Zengchang Pang,Ruqin Gao,Shanpeng Li,Shaojie Wang,Yongmei Liu,Ranran Du,Liang Cheng,Xiaocao Tian,Hua Zhang,Yaoming Zhai,Feng Ning,Xiaohui Sun,Feifei Li,Silu Lv,Junzheng Wang,Wei Hou,Mingyuan Zou,Shichun Yan,Xue Zhou,Bo Yu,Yanjie Li,Qinai Xu,Quan Kang,Ziyan Guo,Ximin Hu,Jinyan Chen,Xiaohuan Wang,Min Weng,Zhendong Guo,Shukuan Wu,Yilei Li,Huimei Li,Ming Wu,Yonglin Zhou,Jinyi Zhou,Ran Tao,Jie Yang,Jian Su,Fang Liu,Jun Zhang,Yihe Hu,Yan Lu,Liangcai Ma,Aiyu Tang,Yujie Hua,Jianrong Jin,Jingchao Liu,Zhenzhu Tang,Naying Chen,Duo Liu,Mingqiang Li,Jinhuai Meng,Rong Pan,Qilian Jiang,Jian Lan,Yun Liu,Liuping Wei,Liyuan Zhou,Ningyu Chen,Ping Wang,Fanwen Meng,Yulu Qin,Sisi Wang,Xianping Wu,Ningmei Zhang,Xiaofang Chen,Xunfu Zhong,Jiaqiu Liu,Qiang Sun,Guojin Luo,Jianguo Li,Xiaofang Chen,Xunfu Zhong,Jiaqiu Liu,Qiang Sun,Pengfei Ge,Xiaolan Ren,Caixia Dong,Hui Zhang,Enke Mao,Zhongxiao Li,Tao Wang,Xi Zhang,Ding Zhang,Gang Zhou,Shixian Feng,Liang Chang,Lei Fan,Yulian Gao,Tianyou He,Huarong Sun,Pan He,Chen Hu,Xukui Zhang,Min Yu,Ruying Hu,Hao Wang,Weiwei Gong,Meng Wang,Chunmei Wang,Xiaoyi Zhang,Kaixu Xie,Lingli Chen,Dongxia Pan,Qijun Gu,Yuelong Huang,Biyun Chen,Li Yin,Huilin Liu,Zhongxi Fu,Qiaohua Xu,Xin Xu,Hao Zhang,Huajun Long,Libo Zhang,Matthew Chun,Tingting Zhu,David Clifton,Benjamin J. Cairns,,,,,
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-95244-8
IF: 4.6
2021-09-02
Scientific Reports
Abstract:Abstract Absolute risks of stroke are typically estimated using measurements of cardiovascular disease risk factors recorded at a single visit. However, the comparative utility of single versus sequential risk factor measurements for stroke prediction is unclear. Risk factors were recorded on three separate visits on 13,753 individuals in the prospective China Kadoorie Biobank. All participants were stroke-free at baseline (2004–2008), first resurvey (2008), and second resurvey (2013–2014), and were followed-up for incident cases of first stroke in the 3 years following the second resurvey. To reflect the models currently used in clinical practice, sex-specific Cox models were developed to estimate 3-year risks of stroke using single measurements recorded at second resurvey and were retrospectively applied to risk factor data from previous visits. Temporal trends in the Cox-generated risk estimates from 2004 to 2014 were analyzed using linear mixed effects models. To assess the value of more flexible machine learning approaches and the incorporation of longitudinal data, we developed gradient boosted tree (GBT) models for 3-year prediction of stroke using both single measurements and sequential measurements of risk factor inputs. Overall, Cox-generated estimates for 3-year stroke risk increased by 0.3% per annum in men and 0.2% per annum in women, but varied substantially between individuals. The risk estimates at second resurvey were highly correlated with the annual increase of risk for each individual (men: r = 0.91, women: r = 0.89), and performance of the longitudinal GBT models was comparable with both Cox and GBT models that considered measurements from only a single visit (AUCs: 0.779–0.811 in men, 0.724–0.756 in women). These results provide support for current clinical guidelines, which recommend using risk factor measurements recorded at a single visit for stroke prediction.
multidisciplinary sciences