Abstract:Diversity-biomass relationships (DBRs) often vary with spatial scale in terrestrial ecosystems, but the mechanisms driving these scale-dependent patterns remain unclear, especially for highly heterogeneous forest ecosystems. This study explores how mutualistic associations between trees and different mycorrhizal fungi, i.e., arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) vs. ectomycorrhizal (EM) association, modulate scale-dependent DBRs. We hypothesized that in soil-heterogeneous forests with a mixture of AM and EM tree species, (i) AM and EM tree species would respond in contrasting ways (i.e., positively vs. negatively, respectively) to increasing soil fertility, (ii) AM tree dominance would contribute to higher tree diversity and EM tree dominance to greater standing biomass, and that as a result (iii) mycorrhizal associations would exert an overall negative effect on DBRs across spatial scales. To empirically test these hypotheses, we collected detailed tree distribution and soil information (e.g., nitrogen, phosphorus, organic matter, pH) from seven temperate and subtropical AM-EM mixed forest megaplots (16-50 ha). Using a spatial codispersion null model and structural equation modeling, we identified the relationships among AM or EM tree dominance, soil fertility, tree species diversity, and biomass and, thus, DBRs across 0.01- to 1-ha scales. We found the first evidence overall supporting the three aforementioned hypotheses in these AM-EM mixed forests: (i) In most forests, with increasing soil fertility, tree communities changed from EM-dominated to AM-dominated; (ii) increasing AM tree dominance had an overall positive effect on tree diversity and a negative effect on biomass, even after controlling for soil fertility and number of trees. Together, (iii) the changes in mycorrhizal dominance along soil fertility gradients weakened the positive DBR observed at 0.01- to 0.04-ha scales in nearly all forests and drove negative DBRs at 0.25- to 1-ha scales in four out of seven forests. Hence, this study highlights a soil-related mycorrhizal dominance mechanism that could partly explain why, in many natural forests, biodiversity-ecosystem functioning (BEF) relationships shift from positive to negative with increasing spatial scale.

Mycorrhizal Type Influences Plant Density Dependence and Species Richness Across 15 Temperate Forests

Differences in Density Dependence among Tree Mycorrhizal Types Affect Tree Species Diversity and Relative Growth Rates

Tree growth response to soil nutrients and neighborhood crowding varies between mycorrhizal types in an old-growth temperate forest

Tree Mycorrhizal Associations Mediate Soil Fertility Effects on Forest Community Structure in a Temperate Forest

Mycorrhizal feedbacks influence global forest structure and diversity

Tree mycorrhizal association types control biodiversity-productivity relationship in a subtropical forest

Symbiotic mycorrhizal types affect patterns of tree aboveground and belowground C allocation in Northeast China

Patterns in spatial distribution and root trait syndromes for ecto and arbuscular mycorrhizal temperate trees in a mixed broadleaf forest

Tree Mycorrhizal Association Types Control Biodiversity- Relationship in a Subtropical Forest

Mycorrhizae mediate diversity effects

Species Abundance is Jointly Determined by Functional Traits and Negative Density Dependence in a Subtropical Forest in Southern China

Scale-dependent diversity-biomass relationships can be driven by tree mycorrhizal association and soil fertility

Mycorrhizal Types Regulate Tree Spatial Associations in Temperate Forests: Ectomycorrhizal Trees Might Favour Species Coexistence

Arbuscular mycorrhizal trees influence the latitudinal beta-diversity gradient of tree communities in forests worldwide

Greater Variations of Rhizosphere Effects Within Mycorrhizal Group Than Between Mycorrhizal Group in a Temperate Forest

The Interactive Effects of Soil Fertility and Tree Mycorrhizal Association Explain Spatial Variation of Diversity–biomass Relationships in a Subtropical Forest

Climate and Mycorrhizae Mediate the Relationship of Tree Species Diversity and Carbon Stocks in Subtropical Forests

Mycorrhizal Type Governs Foliar and Root Multi-Elemental Stoichiometries of Trees Mainly Via Root Traits

Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Fungi Associated With Tree Species In A Planted Forest Of Eastern China

Tree growth and density enhanced, while diversity and spatial clustering reduced soil mycorrhizal C and N sequestration: Strong interaction with soil properties in northeastern China

Conspecific Negative Density Dependence of Trees Varies with Plant Functional Traits and Environmental Conditions Across Scales in a 60‐ha Tropical Rainforest Dynamics Plot