Abstract:The debate between stick (penalties) and carrot (rewards) strategies has been widely carried out in various academic realms, including transportation. This paper seeks to compare the instantaneous and longitudinal effectiveness of a traditional penalty-based congestion pricing strategy and an innovative Incentive-Based Traffic Demand Management (IBTDM) strategy using an online interactive laboratory experiment focused on departure time choice. We also investigate the social-economic phenomena of loss aversion and risk aversion. The experimental results show that penalties and rewards can both positively induce sustainable travel behavior. The stronger demand-shifting performance of the penalty-based strategy at first demonstrates that ‘loss aversion’ does exist in TDM, at least initially. However, this loss aversion weakens as the experiment continues, which verifies the myopic loss aversion theory. Moreover, risky decision-making in the gambling games proves the existence of risk seeking, which violates the ‘certainty effect’. To overcome the disadvantage of laboratory experiment that participants need to accomplish the experiment all in once for considerably long time, an agent-based model is calibrated based on real participants’ behavior to further verify the long-term effectiveness of penalties and rewards, and to verify the effectiveness of other optimized penalty/reward schemes. The simulated results based on the agent-based model indicate that the theoretical optimal penalty scheme performs better in general in congestion alleviation, while a more reasonable reward scheme that considers psychological factors can achieve the same effectiveness in terms of total system travel time reduction. The findings of this research can be used to guide the design of TDM strategies, and the behavioral data collection approach based on our laboratory experiment is portable for future studies.

A Stochastic User Equilibrium Model under Traffic Rationing Based on Mode Shifting Rate

Reversed Traffic Assignment for Staggered Shifts with User Equilibrium

A Combined Modal and Route Choice Behavioral Complementarity Equilibrium Model with Users of Vehicles and Electric Bicycles

Rationing and Pricing Strategies for Congestion Mitigation under Heterogeneous Users and Vehicle Types

Stochastic Transportation Network Considering ATIS with the Information of Environmental Cost

Stochastic User Equilibrium Model with Elastic Demand Based on Bounded Rationality

Optimization Method of Alternate Traffic Restriction Scheme Based on Elastic Demand and Mode Choice Behavior

Tradable permits for traffic management with user heterogeneity

Research on Mixed User Equilibrium Model Based on Mobile Internet Traffic Information Service.

Model and Algorithm of Optimizing Alternate Traffic Restriction Scheme in Urban Traffic Network

Modeling the Effects of Public Bicycle Schemes in A Congested Multi-Modal Road Network

Distance-Based Congestion Pricing with Day-to-Day Dynamic Traffic Flow Evolution Process

Dynamic traffic congestion pricing model for multi-class and multi-mode systems

Optimization and Comparative Analysis of Traffic Restriction Policy by Jointly Considering Carpool Exemptions

Modified Stochastic User-Equilibrium Assignment Algorithm for Urban Rail Transit under Network Operation

Bus-based Park-and-ride System: a Stochastic Model on Multimodal Network with Congestion Pricing Schemes

Efficiency of the Plate-Number-Based Traffic Rationing in General Networks

Stochastic Network User Equilibrium and Traffic System Evolution Based on Reference-Dependent Utility Theory.

Stick or Carrot for Traffic Demand Management? Evidence from Experimental Economics

Inefficiency of Marginal-Cost Tolls in Transportation Networks with Stochastic Demands

Congestion Behavior and Tolls in a Bottleneck Model with Stochastic Capacity