A Meta-analysis of the Effects of Organic and Inorganic Fertilizers on the Soil Microbial Community

WANG Jiangwei,ZHANG Guangyu,YU Chengqun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5814/j.issn.1674-764x.2020.03.007
2020-01-01
Journal of Resources and Ecology
Abstract:In order to investigate the general tendency of soil microbial community responses to fertilizers,a meta-analysis approach was used to synthesise observations on the effects of inorganic and organic fertilizer addi-tion(N: nitrogen; P: phosphorus; NP: nitrogen and phosphorus; PK: phosphorus and potassium; NPK: nitrogen,phosphorus and potassium; OF: organic fertilizer; OF+NPK: organic fertilizer plus NPK)on soil microbial communi-ties.Among the various studies,PK,NPK,OF and OF+NPK addition increased total phospholipid fatty acid(PLFA)by 52.0%,19.5%,334.3%and 58.3%,respectively; while NP,OF and OF+NPK addition increased fungi by 5.6%,21.0%and 8.2%,respectively.NP,NPK and OF addition increased bacteria by 6.4%,9.8%and 13.3%,respectively;while NP and NPK addition increased actinomycetes by 7.0%and 14.8%,respectively.Addition of ammonium ni-trate rather than urea decreased gram-negative bacteria(G-).N addition increased total PLFA、bacteria and ac-tinomycetes in croplands,but decreased fungi and bacteria in forests,and the F/B ratio in grasslands.NPK addition increased total PLFA in forests but not in croplands.The N addition rate was positively correlated with the effects of N addition on gram-positive bacteria(G+)and G-.Therefore,different fertilizers appear to have different effects on the soil microbial community.Organic fertilizers can have a greater positive effect on the soil microbial community than inorganic fertilizers.The effects of fertilizers on the soil microbial community varied with ecosystem types.The effect of N addition on the soil microbial community was related to both the forms of nitrogen that were added and the nitrogen addition rate.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?