Abstract:BACKGROUND:Although the accreditation approach is widely used to ensure the quality of medical education in many countries, there is scant empirical evidence on whether and how it improves actual medical school performance. We focused on conditions in China, which introduced an accreditation system during the 2010s. Specifically, we examined the relationship between first-round accreditation and actual performance based on the results of medical licensing examinations. Referring to organisation theory, we hypothesised that the impacts of accreditation would depend on existing performance gaps.METHOD:In 2022, we analysed panel data from 105 Chinese medical schools during accreditation (2012 to 2021) and pass rates on medical licensing examinations (2011 to 2019), as matched into 834 school-year records in a window of years before and after accreditation. We employed fixed-effects regression models with a comparison group to exclude factors that may have confounded the impacts of accreditation time. We also demonstrated the heterogeneous effects of accreditation by tier and performance gap of medical schools.RESULTS:The conservative estimates showed a substantial cumulative improvement (over 15 percentage points) in pass rates during the years before accreditation, with no clear trend indicating performance drops in the years after accreditation. Lower-tiered medical schools gained greater benefits from accreditation. Medical schools with a larger prior performance gap achieved a greater percentage point increase in pass rates with the passage of time in pre-accreditation years.CONCLUSIONS:This is the first empirical study to investigate whether accreditation has bridged performance gaps among medical schools. The results support the value of accreditation in China, a country that recently established the system, and might work as a substitute for missing information on early accreditation history in countries with long-established accreditation systems. We encourage more studies in countries that have recently introduced accreditation systems.

The Philosophical Thinking on the Reform of Higher Medical Education under the Background of Medical Professional Accreditation

Accreditation of medical education in Australia:observation and thinking

Exploration on Training Mode Reform of Professional Degree of Clinical Medicine Master in Certain University

Evaluation and Analysis of the Accreditation of the Chinese Medical Education (Undergraduate)

Underlying Issues in the Clinical Professional Postgraduates Teaching and Education Mode

Professionalism and Medical Education:Reflections and Strategy for Reform

Study on the Transition Ways of Medical Curriculum to the International Standards

Current status and reflections on the study of the effectiveness of international accreditation of medical education

Thinkings on the reform of medical education system in China

Improving quality of medical education by enhancing quality education of medical students

Effects of Social Changes on Higher Medical Education and Implications for Reform

International Situations of Higher Medical Education and Its Strategy Enlightenments

Comparison and Reflection of Different Accreditation Index Systems for Medical Clinical Centers and Key Disciplines

High Quality Development of Comprehensive University Medical Education In China: Problems And Path In The New Era

Developing Education in Medical Professional Degree for Applied Talents Cultivation

Reform of Medical Education in Holistic Education Perspective

Discussion of Curriculum Reform for Medical Graduates

First-round Accreditation and Pass Rates on Licensing Examination at Different Medical Schools in China: Closing the Performance Gap.

Doctors in China: Improving Quality Through Modernisation of Residency Education

A Review of World Medical Education and Some Thoughts on Eight-Year Medical Education Program of China

Full-time Doctor of Medicine in China: Current Status,problems and Solutions from Special Assessment Perspective