Comparison of Torsional Mode and Conventional Hyper-Pulse Mode in Treatment of Different Grade Nucleus Cataract

WANG Yu-lan,SHENG Yao-hua,TAO Jin-hua,WANG Min,LAN Ying-xia
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1006-4443.2012.03.010
2012-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the efficacy and safety of phacoemulsification of different nucleus density using torsional modality and conventional hyper-pulse mode. Methods A total of 133eyes (125 patients) of different nucleus density level (LOCS Ⅱ criteria grade H 34 eyes,grade Ⅲ48 eyes,grade Ⅳ 51 eyes) were randomly assigned into 2 groups,torsional group (Tor group) and conventional ultrasound hyper-pulse motion group (HP group).All surgeries were performed by a single experienced surgeon.Intraoperative parameters were TEP (Total Equivalent Power),EPT (Effective Phaco Time) and CED (Cumulative Dissipated Energy) and surgical complications.Postoperative outcomes were evaluated by visual acuity,endothelial cell counting,and average central comeal thickness. Results Grade Ⅱ nucleus dealing:EPT and CDE of HP group was significantly higher than the Tor group (P <0.05).Grade Ⅲ and Grade Ⅳ nucleus dealing:EPT showed no difference between two groups,CDE of HP group was significantly lower than Tor group (13.38±2.85 vs 29.66±6.79 in Grade Ⅱ and 23.26±10.76 s vs 34.23±15.99s in Grand Ⅳ).There were no difference of central corneal cell loss rate and corneal edema rate on one day or one week after surgery between two groups.The corneal thickness increase was significantly less in HP group than Tor group (11.57±9.37% vs 19.02± 10.32%,P <0.05). Conclusions Both torsional modality and conventional hyper-pulse mode can deal with all kinds of nucleus effectively and safely.Torsional modality is more efficacy and quick deal in soft cataract.Hyper-pulse mode is more stable and save accumulated energy in hard cataract.Hyper-pulse mode seems to be a safe and wise choice to dealing patients with hard nucleus,older age or lower corneal cell counting.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?