Abstract:The proper definition of the kinesthetic or movement (M) category has been the subject of many controversies within the Rorschach community; see, for example, the discussion between Kramer and Exner (Kramer, 1991; Exner, 1991). The present paper elucidates the nature of movement responses by means of a theoretical analysis of some of the key concepts involved. This analysis in part is of a philosophical character, but I also bring in several recent results from the psychology and neurophysiology of perception which in my opinion are crucial to a correct understanding of the movement responses. The first two parts of the essay describe the basic controversy between those Rorschach theorists who – like Hermann Rorschach himself and Ewald Bohm – hold that kinesthetic identification is a necessary ingredient in any movement response, and those – like John Exner – who want to drop this condition from the definition. This controversy is shown to involve another fundamental issue, namely: In what sense is movement a determinant, and what should be meant by a determinant? The third section also discusses a main objection against keeping Rorschach’s original definition: its reliance on introspective criteria. The fourth part takes a historical perspective, describing the philosophical and psychological tradition called associationism, discussing certain ideas concerning kinesthetic sensibility brought forward within that tradition, and finally analyzing the nature and extent of Hermann Rorschach’s commitment to associationism, especially as manifested in his doctoral dissertation. Some main elements of the 20th-century psychological and philosophical critique of associationism are outlined in Sections 5–6, and the relevance of this critique for the definition of a movement response is explained. Converging evidence from different sources, such as child psychology and clinical and primate neuropsychology, is then brought together in Section 7 to show that recent work on perception supports Hermann Rorschach’s basic intuition about the M category. In Section 8, a new definition of movement responses is given in terms of practical perception and immediate visuo-motor couplings. Finally, in Section 9, the possible use of Rorschach data in the experimental analysis of motion-from-form perception is pointed out.

The Impact on Risky Decision-Making in Patients with Insular Glioma

Differential Effects of Insular and Ventromedial Prefrontal Cortex Lesions on Risky Decision-Making.

Decision‐making impairments under ambiguous and risky situations in patients with prefrontal tumor: A neuropsychological study

Author Response for "decision‐making Impairments under Ambiguous and Risky Situations in Patients with Prefrontal Tumor: A Neuropsychological Study"

The relation between Insular and the memory deficits in patients with posttraumatic stress disorder

Risk-Sensitive Decision-Making in Patients with Posterior Parietal and Ventromedial Prefrontal Cortex Injury

The Contributions of Lesion Laterality and Lesion Volume to Decision-Making Impairment Following Frontal Lobe Damage.

Neural correlates of risk taking in patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder during risky decision-making

Functional Cerebral Specialization and Decision Making in the Iowa Gambling Task: A Single-Case Study of Left-Hemispheric Atrophy and Hemispherotomy

A Comparison Study on Cognitive Function in Patients with Single Subcortical Lesion Stroke of Four Different Areas

Ncog-31. Neurocognitive Outcome Following Awake Craniotomy For Insular Glioma Resection: Impact Of Surgical Approach And Tumor Classification

What is the cognitive footprint of insular glioma?

Is There a Recovery of Decision-Making Function after Frontal Lobe Damage? A Study Using Alternative Versions of the Iowa Gambling Task

Decision-making processes following damage to the prefrontal cortex.

Relationships between executive function, working memory, and decision-making on the Iowa Gambling Task: Evidence from ventromedial patients, dorsolateral patients, and normal subjects.

Transcortical Insular Glioma Resection: Clinical Outcome and Predictors

Rorschach’s Idea of a “Movement” Response in the Light of Recent Philosophy and Psychology of Perception

The electrophysiology and structural difference between humans with distinct risky preference: a study based on EEG and MRI

An Event-Related Fmri Study on Risk Taking by Healthy Individuals of High or Low Impulsiveness

The techniques of surgery possible in incurable obstructive carcinoma of the corpus ventriculi.

F62. RISKY DECISION-MAKING PERFORMANCE IN PATIENTS WITH EARLY SCHIZOPHRENIA-SPECTRUM DISORDER