Abstract:Study questionDoes cryoprotection of spermatozoa using a vitrification protocol with improved cryoprotective agents and a novel device for large storage lead to better outcomes than conventional slow freezing?Summary answerVitrification of human sperm using sucrose and dextran-based cryoprotectant (CPA4) with a new vitrification device resulted in significantly better sperm motility and progressive motility and improved DNA integrity with lower DNA fragmentation compared with conventional slow freezing.What is known alreadyA major limitation to clinical implementation of vitrification is the right balance between the volume of spermatozoa suspension cryopreserved and a standardised use of CPAs for survival of spermatozoa.Study design, size, durationThis was a control versus current clinical practice study using 30 fresh human semen samples to carry out the different cryoprotectant analyses followed by a further 23 semen samples to test the novel vitrification protocol.Participants/materials, setting, methodsAll human specimens fulfilled the following criteria: > 5 million spermatozoa/mL, > 20% total motility, ≥ 1.8 mL in volume, with all participants falling within the age range of 25–45 inclusively. The concentration, progressive motility, non-progressive motility, immotility, and various morphokinetic variables including DAP, DCL, DSL, LIN, and STR were then determined using the IVOS II™ Clinical CASA system (Hamilton Thorne, Beverly, MA, USA) on the basis of the 5th Edition of WHO Laboratory Manual for the Examination and Processing of Human Semen.Main results and the role of chanceAmong the 6 cryopreservation methods in this study, vitrification with the funnel-shaped device using CPA4 best preserves the 13 sperm parameters evaluated by CASA system. Conventional slow freezing and vitrification with the device using seminal plasma also protects sperm quality, but the overall motilities are statistically lower in comparison with the novel vitrification approach with cryoprotective media using the device. DNA fragmentation significantly increased after cryopreservation through the method of conventional slow freezing (p = 0.07). There was no significant difference in DNA fragmentation between fresh control and vitrification (p = 1.000).Limitations, reasons for cautionExtensive training is required to minimise the human error in using the vitrification device to perform cryopreservation. Each operator can only handle one sample at a time with device vitrification, whereas several samples can be processed without the need for special training with conventional slow freezing.Wider implications of the findingsThe presented study shows that a new vitrification method could improve survival sperm rate. Human sperm vitrification using our novel protocol gives higher motility and progression and lower percentage of DNA fragmentation than conventional slow freezing. Our findings indicate that this method could supersede the current clinical practice in particular for patients with oligospermia as it reduces osmotic damage, time, and cost.

Effects of straw direct vapor nitrogen method on the motility of post-thaw human sperm

Effects of Vapor Nitrogen Freezing Method and Direct Liquid Nitrogen Freezing Method on Motility, Morphology and Ultrastructure of Human Sperm

Comparision of Two Cryopreservative Methods on the Motility of Post-Thaw Human Sperm

The effect of cryopreservative methods on motility parameters of human spermatozoa

Effects of the novel cryovial vector on cryosurvival rate of human semen

The optimal protocols for sperm freezing in human sperm banks

Differential Motility Parameters and Identification of Proteomic Profiles of Human Sperm Cryopreserved with Cryostraw and Cryovial

[Influence of Cryoprotectant with Glycerol and Freezing-Thawing Procedure on the Motility of Human Sperm].

Effects of Cryopreservative Methods and Cryopreservative Mediums on Sperm Viability and Hypotonic Swelling Rate of Human Spermatozoa Tail

Improving Native Human Sperm Freezing Protection By Using A Modified Vitrification Method

Effects of different proportions of cryoprotectant to seminal plasma on the motility of post-thaw human sperm]

A Simple and Efficient Method to Cryopreserve Human Ejaculated and Testicular Spermatozoa in −80°C Freezer

Sequential Interval Micro-Droplet Loading in Closed Hemi-Straw Carrier System: A Convenient and Efficient Method for Ultra-Rapid Cryopreservation in Extreme Oligozoospermia.

Liquid Nitrogen Vapor is Comparable to Liquid Nitrogen for Storage of Cryopreserved Human Sperm: Evidence from the Characteristics of Post-Thaw Human Sperm

The effect of two cryopreservation methods on human sperm DNA damage.

Comparison of different freezing methods for micro-volume semen

Comparison of cryopreserved human sperm from solid surface vitrification and standard vapor freezing method: on motility, morphology, vitality and DNA integrity

Effects of Different Diluents and Freezing Methods on Cryopreservation of Hu Ram Semen

Ultra-Rapid Freezing and Rapid Freezing Methods in Clinical ICSI Program: Effects on Sperm Biological Characteristics, DNA Methylation Stability, DNA Methyltransferase Activity, and Embryo Morphokinetics

Improved cryopreservation of spermatozoa using vitrification: comparison of cryoprotectants and a novel device for long-term storage