Medical Education Reform in China: the Shanghai Medical Training Model.
Jialin C Zheng,Han Zhang,Beiqing Wu,Zenghan Tong,Yingbo Zhu,Matthew S Mitchell,Xiaoting Sun,Yuhong Yang,Kan Zhang,Lv Fang,Eli Adashi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4300/jgme-d-20-00069.1
2020-01-01
Journal of Graduate Medical Education
Abstract:I n China, a growing and aging population has challenged the health care system. It is expected that China’s population over 65 years old will reach 487 million, or nearly 35% of inhabitants, in 2050. The burden on the health care system will be exacerbated by difficulty in accessing medical resources, especially in rural areas. The training of physicians who are qualified, respected, and trusted to serve in rural and urban communities must be increased to meet this need. The concept of graduate medical education is relatively new in China. Traditionally, medical school graduates work directly as junior physicians without residency training after finishing medical school. With theoretical knowledge and clinical clerkships obtained in medical school, junior physicians’ practical skills and knowledge were gradually acquired through an apprenticeship model, learning from senior physicians in the same department over an indefinite number of years. The training experience is variable in terms of length and quality, as there is no standardization or oversight. This inconsistency has led to a devaluation of physicians practicing in the community, away from teaching hospitals. Many patients prefer to be treated in tertiary centers as the physicians there learned from the experts. Patients may self-refer to specialists or physicians with more experience, resulting in an overloading of tertiary hospitals and underutilization of physicians practicing in community and rural areas. Given this social stigma, early career physicians tend to choose tertiary hospitals at the start of their medical career and are reluctant to work in community health care centers or regional hospitals, because they have insufficient social recognition and resources. Thus, reform in health care service delivery, particularly in the medical education system, is warranted to cultivate more primary care physicians and community-based and rural providers through standardized medical training. These reforms would need to incorporate improved standardization and quality while being timely and cost-effective to encourage institutional implementation and student recruitment. In 2009, the Chinese government launched a national health care reform policy, of which medical education reform is a key part. In 2010, Shanghai was chosen to be the pilot city for the national reform because it had relatively mature medical and educational resources. Several local health and education departments united and formed a special health reform leadership group to formulate plans and supervise the implementation. Shanghai’s reform aims to create a better physician training system, enhance professional prestige, and promote a more harmonious medical care environment with better physician-patient relationships and improved learning environments for trainees. The 2 pillars of Shanghai’s medical education reform are standardized residency training and standardized specialist training, with the aim of cultivating medical personnel of homogenized quality and high-level standards through a well-functioning postgraduate medical education system. There are 5 essential parts to Shanghai’s health care reform: the ‘‘5þ3þ3’’ model (5-year bachelor’s degree in medical school, plus 3year residency training, plus 3-year specialty training), a standardized residency training, a primary care system, a health information project, and vertical integration of medical resources. After graduation from the standardized residency training (SRT), trainees obtain a certificate that is recognized throughout the country, indicating that they have completed residency training and can be recruited by health care institutes of different levels all over the nation as registered physicians. In this article, we describe the 5þ3þ3 model and its potential for dissemination throughout China’s medical education system. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.4300/JGME-D-20-00069.1