Abstract:Background: Positron emission tomography (PET) has been investigated for its ability to reconstruct proton-induced positron activity distributions in proton therapy. This technique holds potential for range verification in clinical practice. Recently, deep learning-based dose estimation from positron activity distributions shows promise for in vivo proton dose monitoring and guided proton therapy. Purpose: This study evaluates the effectiveness of three classical neural network models, recurrent neural network (RNN), U-Net, and Transformer, for proton dose estimating. It also investigates the characteristics of these models, providing valuable insights for selecting the appropriate model in clinical practice. Methods: Proton dose calculations for spot beams were simulated using Geant4. Computed tomography (CT) images from four head cases were utilized, with three for training neural networks and the remaining one for testing. The neural networks were trained with one-dimensional (1D) positron activity distributions as inputs and generated 1D dose distributions as outputs. The impact of the number of training samples on the networks was examined, and their dose prediction performance in both homogeneous brain and heterogeneous nasopharynx sites was evaluated. Additionally, the effect of positron activity distribution uncertainty on dose prediction performance was investigated. To quantitatively evaluate the models, mean relative error (MRE) and absolute range error (ARE) were used as evaluation metrics. Results: The U-Net exhibited a notable advantage in range verification with a smaller number of training samples, achieving approximately 75% of AREs below 0.5 mm using only 500 training samples. The networks performed better in the homogeneous brain site compared to the heterogeneous nasopharyngeal site. In the homogeneous brain site, all networks exhibited small AREs, with approximately 90% of the AREs below 0.5 mm. The Transformer exhibited the best overall dose distribution prediction, with approximately 92% of MREs below 3%. In the heterogeneous nasopharyngeal site, all networks demonstrated acceptable AREs, with approximately 88% of AREs below 3 mm. The Transformer maintained the best overall dose distribution prediction, with approximately 85% of MREs below 5%. The performance of all three networks in dose prediction declined as the uncertainty of positron activity distribution increased, and the Transformer consistently outperformed the other networks in all cases. Conclusions: Both the U-Net and the Transformer have certain advantages in the proton dose estimation task. The U-Net proves well suited for range verification with a small training sample size, while the Transformer outperforms others at dose-guided proton therapy.

Region-specific Three-Dimensional Dose Distribution Prediction: a Feasibility Study on Prostate VMAT Cases

Dosimetric Analysis of Radiation Treatment Plans Based on a Deep Learning Auto Contouring Model for Patients with Localized Prostate Cancer

Automated Clinical Target Volume Delineation Using Deep 3D Neural Networks in Radiation Therapy of Non-small Cell Lung Cancer

The Feasibility Study on the Generalization of Deep Learning Dose Prediction Model for Volumetric Modulated Arc Therapy of Cervical Cancer

Feasibility Study of Fast Intensity-Modulated Proton Therapy Dose Prediction Method Using Deep Neural Networks for Prostate Cancer.

A Feasibility Study on Deep Learning Based Individualized 3D Dose Distribution Prediction

Dose Prediction Using a Three-Dimensional Convolutional Neural Network for Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma With Tomotherapy

Predicting voxel-level dose distributions of single-isocenter volumetric modulated arc therapy treatment plan for multiple brain metastases

Dose Prediction with Deep Learning for Prostate Cancer Radiation Therapy: Model Adaptation to Different Treatment Planning Practices

A Comparative Study of Deep Learning Dose Prediction Models for Cervical Cancer Volumetric Modulated Arc Therapy

A feasibility study for predicting optimal radiation therapy dose distributions of prostate cancer patients from patient anatomy using deep learning

A Feasibility Study for Predicting 3D Radiotherapy Dose Distribution of Lung VMAT Patients

Improvement of deep learning prediction model in patient‐specific QA for VMAT with MLC leaf position map and patient's dose distribution

Automatic Treatment Planning Based on Three-Dimensional Dose Distribution Predicted from Deep Learning Technique.

Proton spot dose estimation based on positron activity distributions with neural network

Predicting 3D dose distribution with scale attention network for prostate cancer radiotherapy

AS-NeSt: A Novel 3D Deep Learning Model for Radiation Therapy Dose Distribution Prediction in Esophageal Cancer Treatment with Multiple Prescriptions

A feasibility study to predict 3D dose delivery accuracy for IMRT using DenseNet with log files

AS-NeSt: a Novel 3D Deep Learning Model for Radiotherapy Dose Distribution Prediction on Esophageal Cancer Treatment with Multiple Prescriptions

Prediction of dose distributions for non‐small cell lung cancer patients using MHA‐ResUNet

Deep learning-based dose prediction for magnetic resonance-guided prostate radiotherapy