Abstract:Background: In 2020, our center established a Tanner-Whitehouse 3 (TW3) artificial intelligence (AI) system using a convolutional neural network (CNN), which was built upon 9059 radiographs. However, the system, upon which our study is based, lacked a gold standard for comparison and had not undergone thorough evaluation in different working environments. Methods: To further verify the applicability of the AI system in clinical bone age assessment (BAA) and to enhance the accuracy and homogeneity of BAA, a prospective multi-center validation was conducted. This study utilized 744 left-hand radiographs of patients, ranging from 1 to 20 years of age, with 378 boys and 366 girls. These radiographs were obtained from nine different children's hospitals between August and December 2020. The BAAs were performed using the TW3 AI system and were also reviewed by experienced reviewers. Bone age accuracy within 1 year, root mean square error (RMSE), and mean absolute error (MAE) were statistically calculated to evaluate the accuracy. Kappa test and Bland-Altman (B-A) plot were conducted to measure the diagnostic consistency. Results: The system exhibited a high level of performance, producing results that closely aligned with those of the reviewers. It achieved a RMSE of 0.52 years and an accuracy of 94.55% for the radius, ulna, and short bones series. When assessing the carpal series of bones, the system achieved a RMSE of 0.85 years and an accuracy of 80.38%. Overall, the system displayed satisfactory accuracy and RMSE, particularly in patients over 7 years old. The system excelled in evaluating the carpal bone age of patients aged 1-6. Both the Kappa test and B-A plot demonstrated substantial consistency between the system and the reviewers, although the model encountered challenges in consistently distinguishing specific bones, such as the capitate. Furthermore, the system's performance proved acceptable across different genders and age groups, as well as radiography instruments. Conclusions: In this multi-center validation, the system showcased its potential to enhance the efficiency and consistency of healthy delivery, ultimately resulting in improved patient outcomes and reduced healthcare costs.

Radiographs and Texts Fusion Learning Based Deep Networks for Skeletal Bone Age Assessment

Bone age assessment based on deep neural networks with annotation-free cascaded critical bone region extraction.

A Multi-Scale Data Fusion Framework for Bone Age Assessment with Convolutional Neural Networks.

Bone Age Assessment with X-Ray Images Based on Contourlet Motivated Deep Convolutional Networks

A Global-Local Feature Fusion Convolutional Neural Network for Bone Age Assessment of Hand X-ray Images

Diagnostic Performance of Convolutional Neural Network-Based Tanner-Whitehouse 3 Bone Age Assessment System.

Automated Skeletal Bone Age Assessment with Two-Stage Convolutional Transformer Network Based on X-ray Images

A Deep Automated Skeletal Bone Age Assessment Model Via Region-Based Convolutional Neural Network

Validation of an Established TW3 Artificial Intelligence Bone Age Assessment System: a Prospective, Multicenter, Confirmatory Study

Region fine-grained attention network for accurate bone age assessment

Bone Age Assessment By Deep Convolutional Neural Networks Combined With Clinical Tw3-Rus

Skeletal Bone Age Assessments for Young Children Based on Regression Convolutional Neural Networks.

SMANet: Multi-Region Ensemble of Convolutional Neural Network Model for Skeletal Maturity Assessment

Symmetry-Based Fusion Algorithm for Bone Age Detection with YOLOv5 and ResNet34

Bone Age Estimation with X-ray Images Based on EfficientNet Pre-training Model

An Unsupervised Deep-Learning Method for Bone Age Assessment

Extract Bone Parts Without Human Prior: End-to-end Convolutional Neural Network for Pediatric Bone Age Assessment

Assessment of Bone Age Based on Hand Radiographs Using Regression-Based Multi-Modal Deep Learning

Pediatric Bone Age Assessment Using Deep Convolutional Neural Networks

Bone age assessment by multi-granularity and multi-attention feature encoding